zondag 17 september 2023

Goodbye Horses - The Grayzone live

Goodbye Horses - The Grayzone live

300K subscribers
Max Blumenthal and Wyatt Reed discuss threats from Ukrainian officials to assassinate journalists and unleash a terror wave as Senate Democrats demand a probe into Elon Musk for refusing to participating in a Pearl Harbor style attack on Russia. They will also cover the hypocrisy around calls for Libya aid.


NL
0:24 / 1:35:46
Transcript
0:02
hey what's up everybody Welcome to The Gray Zone it's me Max Blumenthal here with
0:10
American journalist Wyatt Reed American journalist on a list of many lists of
0:18
Traders Wyatt Reed how's it going Wyatt
0:24
good I'm I'm thinking of starting a list of my lists so I don't forget all the
0:29
lists that I've been listed on well we'll talk about your your list we'll get into that
0:35
yeah congratulations uh thanks to everyone you're our
0:42
managing editor for uh the next two years at least so uh congratulations on
0:48
that and uh I hope you're managing
0:53
we just like made up some managing titles
0:59
it works I think right yeah I mean it's all like what am I am I
1:04
like editor Emeritus now like editor-in-chief
1:10
but basically you know I haven't had a day-to-day Editor to work with before
1:15
and it's increasing our productivity um there are there are very few people out there who actually can write
1:21
consecutive words in English that make sense who also understand the subject matter on a granular level that we're
1:27
working with so I went deep into the Appalachian
1:33
Backwoods it was kind of like journalistic version of Deliverance
1:38
why it was there who out there looking for Papa's and ginseng and he found me
1:43
instead no I met I met you through a more interesting Saga we'll we'll tell
1:49
another time um shinatova to everyone who's observing
1:55
to all the uh tribe out there white are you are you am I do I remember
2:01
right that you're part Jewish I'm Jewish enough let's leave it at that
2:07
you're Jewish well I mean you're
2:12
you're jewishness went up Jewish enough to work at the gray Zone you're in the media so that works
2:23
yeah we've actually expanded right yeah it's uh Jewish
2:30
so um yeah it's the Jewish New Year
2:35
um we're all going to be inscribed in The Book of Life or and uh it will be
2:42
determined whether we'll die horrific deaths in the next few days or whether we'll get to
2:47
live anyway now that we have all that out of the way
2:53
we'll get into welcome everybody especially from uh
2:58
from out of the U.S we have such a wide widespread Global audience
3:04
we hope to visit you all and do Gray Zone shows across the world but hopefully I think
3:11
you know in this next year or so I want to start doing some
3:17
actual live shows in the U.S so we'll see if that's possible um
3:23
anyway right now here in Washington there is a coordinated freak out targeting one of the wealthiest men in
3:30
the world not because he is hoarding wealth or because of inequality
3:36
because or because um I don't know he's seeking to control
3:42
foreign data of millions and millions of people but because he's insufficiently war-like
3:49
we're talking about Elon Musk obviously Elon Musk who is in charge of the former
3:56
Twitter social media platform now known as X and also the X Empire the Tesla Empire
4:06
um major government contractor someone who previously got good press and was
4:11
this is the subject of a biography by Walter Isaacson who's one of the most famous mainstream biographers in the U.S
4:19
he is a liberal you know associated with the Democratic Party
4:25
um but musk gave him some access because why wouldn't you I mean the book is going to be in the front of every
4:31
airport bookstore about yourself I mean Walter Isaacson is really like
4:37
the mainstream biographer right now he's sort of like Robert Caro
4:43
but maybe a lot less interesting anyway so Walter Isaacson published a piece in
4:51
the Washington Post last weekend about how Elon Musk had supposedly thwarted I
4:56
don't know if that was the language he used thwarted thwarted a Ukrainian attack on the Russian Navy naval fleet
5:02
at sevastopol which is one of the key Frontline Russian Naval bases
5:09
um it's what it's a big part of the reason that this war even happened in this spot yeah right
5:16
yeah so it was going to be a Pearl Harbor style attack um by on unmanned aerial Vehicles unmanned
5:24
basically submarine drones and they needed Elon musk's starlink communication system to participate and
5:30
so the way Isaacson framed it initially was that musk actually turned it off to
5:36
avoid uh being a part of this and then said I I didn't sign up to be part of uh some War Coalition I'm just a private
5:43
U.S citizen and I thought I was bringing peace and helping people in Ukraine by giving them Starling which is true I
5:49
mean in a way it's true he was providing them with a free charity service when Russia had taken out their
5:55
satellite system early on during the Russian military operation that began in
6:02
February 2022 so musk stepped in out of the you know after being asked to and
6:07
gave them what they needed and it's triggered a freak out and and the Freak Out is very specific to the
6:14
Democratic party Democratic party talking points are being distributed to attack Elon Musk over this we'll get
6:21
into that I think the initial Salvo
6:26
was launched by Jake Tapper who is sort of like the leading neocon
6:35
personality at CNN someone who and he had an interview with
6:40
Tony blinken last weekend and just went off on him you know he and
6:45
he this is the thing Jake Tapper and the rest of the corporate media neocons they
6:51
will never challenge a billionaire or a western official unless they are insufficiently militaristic otherwise it
6:57
was just a softball interview but then this part unfolded uh has recently confirmed a report that's in Walter
7:04
isaacson's new biography at mosque that last year musk blocked access to his
7:10
Starling satellite Network in Crimea in order to disrupt the major Ukrainian attack on the Russian Navy there in
7:16
other words musk effectively sabotaged a military operation by Ukraine a U.S Ally
7:24
against Russia an aggressor country that invaded a U.S Ally should there be
7:30
repercussions for that Jake I can't speak to a specific episode
7:37
here's what I can tell you I mean and it's anyway so blinken just deflects because what is the Secretary of State
7:43
going to do to Elon Musk like what repercussions are they calling for is he going to announce the nationalization of
7:50
x anyway that and that's what this is all about is like narrative control the
7:57
Democrats feel like they've lost the narrative on the most important social media platform for
8:02
political public figures whether they're journalists or politicians and and what Jake Tapper was doing why it was lying
8:09
he was lying through his teeth that is not what Elon Musk actually
8:15
did and Walter Isaacson following that Jake Tapper interview had to issue a correction
8:22
uh here's Walter Iverson's correct to clarify on the starlink issue the
8:30
ukrainian's thought coverage was enabled all the way to Crimea but it was not they asked musk to enable it for their
8:36
drone sub attack on the Russian Fleet musk did not enable it because he thought probably correctly that would
8:42
cause a major war whoops so anyway this just kind of undercuts the whole
8:48
Narrative of Tapper and the pro-war Democrats but they're still rolling with
8:53
it I like how that's a clarification too it's it's not totally walking back the
9:00
original claim you know that's that should be a retraction right you you said a lie and now you're conceding that
9:06
it was a lie but you're pretending that you were just misunderstood or something also just to point out the United States
9:13
and the Ukraine are not Military Allies they're not a member of NATO uh they are labeled I believe a
9:19
strategic partner under under certain um a certain sense but they're they're they
9:26
are not an ally in any formal sense but this is a claim that gets repeated over and over again this is part of what's
9:31
being used uh to justify the demonization of Elon musk's uh
9:38
well let's we'll get into it here in a second because he musk has actually come out and clarified uh the position
9:45
exactly what happened after following this massive freakout as you noted the
9:52
only time they're ever going to come out of after a billionaire like this is for some perceived transgression against the
9:57
military-industrial complex um but uh it seems to be the case that musk himself was not authorized to turn
10:06
on starlink in the first place not that he you know the so the story has evolved so dramatically over the over the course
10:12
of a couple days first it was that he specifically shut off starlink coverage and now
10:18
now we know that he that coverage was never enabled in the first place and the
10:23
reason why is because to do so would would be to violate U.S sanctions against Russia so uh you know I I
10:32
so we'll we'll get into that here um it might be worth uh putting here's Elon musk's own explanation
10:39
yeah so I mean again it's just undercuts
10:44
The Narrative that the Democrats the Corp like CNN MSNBC are pushing right
10:49
now when you consider that U.S citizens are not allowed to operate in Crimea because
10:57
it's sanctioned here's Elon Musk uh without the volume on and now here's him with the volume on
11:08
um it's actually turned off he's in some vast hall or something so the sound is terrible he's on a plane using starlink
11:17
uh and and and and zooming into this uh Summit in Los Angeles
11:28
sanctions against Russia um and we're not allowed to actually and
11:33
that includes Crimea in the sanctions and we're not allowed to actually turn on
11:39
uh connectivity to essentially the country without explicit government approval
11:44
um so um
11:49
so so basically the uh uh look at you know Ukraine didn't they didn't give us any any event this
11:55
morning or heads up or anything um where we just got the these sort of uh
12:01
urgent calls on the Ukrainian government saying that we needed to turn on Premier it's like in the middle of the night and
12:07
we're like what are you talking about you know what's it for
12:12
I mean they're kind of laughing at the it it it looks it look it sounds silly like oh we're
12:19
doing a military operation let's call some billionaire in the middle of the night uh maybe it'll work and we'll
12:24
destroy Russia's Navy like is that the level that the ukrainians are operating at I mean it's absurd
12:33
this is it is absurd so I mean yes there was the chance as even Walter Isaacson
12:39
acknowledged that this could have caused World War III uh could have caused a
12:44
major military escalation but to me it seems like it would have been just crossing another
12:50
red line while initiating another bungled attack like the Ukrainian Special Forces Landing in Crimea which
12:57
ended in disaster for them as they fail dramatically in the counter-offensive
13:03
they're mounting all these Terror attacks on Crimea and across the Russian Federation
13:09
that don't do any structural damage and usually aren't even successful from a tactical point of view
13:16
um right and then yeah we're basically
13:22
um figuring out what this was kind of like a Pearl Harbor time attack on
13:27
um Sebastopol on the Russian things Festival so they really ask us for to really practically
13:33
take part in a major Act of War um and um
13:40
you know what we certainly have huge FPL support for the painting of it um the
13:45
Ukrainian government is not in charge U.S uh people or companies
13:52
that's not how it works
13:57
do you hear that Applause so here making an excellent point right yeah one of the most popular
14:02
[Applause]
14:08
I should say that that President Biden's biggest fan if if
14:13
I received a Presidential Directive to turn it on I would have done so because I do have
14:18
gone the president as the chief executive officer of the country whether I want that post with the president or not
14:25
I still respect the office and so if you know if we've gotten if I gotten a
14:31
request from the president type of thing but he's America president or from the CIA director
14:39
yeah but then I I worked a real president you know so but osis requests came through
14:45
well that's I mean yeah there's a lot you can say there I mean one kind of secondary point I would make is that
14:55
is is that the Biden Administration is it's unclear if the Biden Administration actually wanted such an attack to take
15:01
place or succeed uh especially at that point they weren't yet ready to attack Crimea but I mean
15:08
what else does that say about you know the relationship between musk and the government Wyatt
15:15
well he's trying to preserve that relationship he doesn't want to kill the Golden Goose this is what's made his
15:22
massive Fortune possible in the first place with all these government contracts these government subsidies for
15:28
all of his companies whether that be SpaceX or Tesla uh he's trying to play nice he's trying to play Both Sides
15:34
basically right you know talking about how absurd and ridiculous this request was but if it had come from our pretend
15:42
president who can barely string two sentences together then of course you would have honored it because you know
15:48
he respects the office or whatever um
15:53
yeah so it's so it's it's really Mount um but you know at this point even a
15:59
mealy mouth two-faced billionaire is is better than than you know the the
16:05
blanket Administration let's call it that because I don't know who is actually really calling the shots at
16:10
this point certainly not by themselves yeah I mean it's the blink in Newland
16:17
it's it's Biden's kitchen cabinet and the then that you have the Pentagon
16:23
and uh white I mean I actually don't have it in front of me but you know on this point
16:29
because what part of the the Democrats criticism which is sort of valid but it's warped of Elon Musk in this
16:37
situation is that the US government shouldn't be relying on billionaires uh to wage a war effort
16:45
for example uh there's a new Senate Democrat letter where they're demanding the Pentagon investigate Elon musk's
16:52
contract it's it's wild the wording you know there here it is Senate Democrats are
16:59
demanding that the Pentagon turnover information about musk's Starling contracts with the US military to investigate whether they're safeguards
17:05
in them to prevent another version of the recent Fiasco the Fiasco in which he didn't
17:11
let the it wasn't even zielinski who was demanding he turn on starlink it was Michael federoff who is the Minister of
17:18
digital transformation so it was some low-level Deputy Prime Minister telling him to do it so failing to listen to a
17:24
foreign Deputy Prime Minister has prompted the Democrats to demand that Pentagon investigate all of an American
17:31
billionaires contracts and they
17:36
um they are aggressively probing the musk Ukraine Fiasco from every angle
17:44
and uh they accuse him of meddling and in and and you know I mean if you read
17:51
they're accusing him of defend effectively defending Russian interests
17:57
um so this is sort of a version of trump Russia where they're targeting they're basically transplanting the Trump Russia
18:04
um narrative onto Elon Musk and we'll talk about what this is about in a
18:09
second but why aren't they asking for a probe of other billionaires and companies that the US
18:17
and Ukraine are relying on entirely for this war effort for example palantir
18:23
which actually Peter Thiel founded but it's run by a guy named Alex karp now who's much more of a bipartisan player
18:31
he was at the last two Bilderberg conferences in Washington and Lisbon Portugal with all the NATO Chief and all
18:39
the five eyes intelligence heads and palantir is responsible for all the
18:45
targeting and maps that the U.S U.S centcom the Pentagon is supplying to the
18:51
Ukrainian military palantir is using AI to develop maps and targeting systems
18:58
it's not uh as though the U.S government is supplying this it's a private
19:04
Corporation that's a private spying Corporation that's involved in so many surveillance scandals
19:11
hoovering up Americans data without their permission and it was actually featured in that
19:17
60-minute segment Wyatt that you tweeted where the 60 Minutes correspondent goes to meet with Mark milley
19:24
and you know send it to me in the private chat or something and I'll throw I'll throw it up on screen but basically
19:29
Millie says we have an open we have open pipes so open intelligence pipes to the ukrainians and it basically shows how
19:35
the US is running Ukrainian operations from the operations room and all those
19:40
maps on screen are from palantir but nobody cares about that in Washington because palantir is doing
19:46
what NATO wants it's doing what Ukraine wants it's doing what the Pentagon wants
19:52
Elon Musk just steps back for a second behaves like a private citizen and then
19:58
all of a sudden the Helen you know fire and fury rains
20:03
down on his head from the Democrats because this is Biden's War coming up on re-election and Elon Musk they're
20:10
they're blaming him basically for screwing up Biden's re-election by by failing to mount this Pearl Harbor style
20:17
attack and what do they care if we go to the brink of nuclear war well and and for following the U.S law
20:25
right for following the sanctions which demand that he receive express permission from the U.S government to be
20:32
able to allow the starlink to be activated over Crimea in the first place
20:38
right yeah uh and yeah I have sent this uh this link to you it's this is this is
20:43
worth uh this video is worth watching too the CBS story that came out recently because it really just shows you how far
20:50
down up the escalation ladder we've gotten uh you know months ago it was it
20:55
was totally forbidden to acknowledge that this is a proxy war now CBS is openly acknowledging it's a proxy war
21:03
um and not seeing the link requirement of the Joint Chiefs and staff uh send it to you on Twitter and in
21:09
WhatsApp uh okay but uh there's a private chat to the right on stream yard
21:14
if you want to do that oh oh uh okay I'm uh using my phone so I can't do that but
21:22
all right I got it uh and so yeah so what's going on here Wyatt
21:28
well this is basically an admission the first kind of admission I've seen from
21:34
the mainstream media that we are indeed engaged in a proxy war there to use
21:39
their words a new Forever War uh against Russia using Ukraine as an intermediary
21:46
something that you and I have been pointing out uh since the beginning of
21:51
this war for a year and a half now we have been explaining that this is what's going on and uh we've been ridiculed and
21:59
attacked for it uh the consensus among the mainstream media has been that
22:04
actually we are simply helping the clucky ukrainians stand up for themselves against the evil Russian
22:09
Empire against evil authoritarian Vladimir Putin who wants to restore the
22:15
Soviet Empire and who sees himself as a new SAR uh but now we're finally kind of
22:20
getting a little bit of the truth and we're getting an inside look at the
22:26
command post at which the us is waging its proxy war against Russia selecting
22:32
targets for the ukrainians and as Millie says uh he uh quote our intelligence
22:39
pipes to Ukraine are quite open range these are unclassified because we're here track the painful progress of the
22:46
offensive it looks like the ukrainians the yellow have cut a pretty good wedge
22:52
out of the uh the Russian lines that's true yeah what physically is that that they've had to get through it's
22:58
minefields boom it's trenches it's ditches it's I mean 10 12 minutes just right there they're showing ukrainians
23:04
just getting wasted in the counter-offensive that was a horrible shot that that video you know that was a
23:11
compressed version that was one of the most horrifying videos I've ever seen uh that video if you watch it in its
23:18
entirety shows an entire armored carrier full of ukrainians get dropped off directly into a Minefield and one by one
23:25
they blow themselves up more of them come out to rescue the other ukrainians who've lost legs and Limbs and then they
23:32
get blown up too uh it's it's horrifying what they're basically subjecting these
23:37
people to they're kidnapping these Ukrainian men off the streets most of them are trying to go into hiding the
23:43
ones that get us that get caught trying to escape or going to work uh they get thrown in the Paddy Wagon and they get
23:50
deposited at some unpre you know undisclosed location perhaps in Poland
23:56
uh and then they get three weeks of basic training shoot a rifle a handful of times and then they get thrown onto
24:02
that um and that's you know five million now we're by Millie right not by not by the
24:09
Ukrainian you know whatever is left of the Ukrainian regime which is just just a a puppet of the people like Mark
24:17
Miller yes disarmed with anti-tank ammunitions
24:24
what other defenses are they going to encounter if they make it through those those Orange Lines you see there are
24:30
Russian trench lines and in between those Orange Lines which you don't but those orange lines all that that's palantir AI Maps I'll see our minefields
24:38
and tank ditches and what's called Dragon's Teeth barbed wire that sort of thing this is a multi-layered Russian
24:44
defense in depth U.S advertises the 44 billion dollars in military equipment it
24:50
has committed to Ukraine but says very little about the equally valuable intelligence do you share what you know
24:58
about Russian troop movements with Ukraine our intelligence pipes to Ukraine are quite open uh for sure and
25:04
of course the CIA and interagency NSX all those guys so but there's pretty open pipes on Intel to Ukraine so are
25:11
you helping Ukraine select Targets target selection and authority to strike
25:16
is with Ukraine what we do is provide them situational awareness would you tell them there's a command post over
25:22
there there's an ammunition dump over there we'll give them the situational awareness uh as best we can tell so this
25:29
really is a uh a proxy war you don't have boots on the ground you're not making decisions but you're helping
25:35
Ukraine kill Russians we're helping Ukraine defend themselves is what we're doing the Ukrainian goal is to reach he
25:42
doesn't say that it's not a proxy war he's basically like yeah pretty much right
25:48
so he says he says what people like you know uh Mitt Romney I I there's uh
25:56
Lindsey Graham have have all been saying which is you know this is actually a wonderful situation for us this is kind
26:02
of what he's getting at oh we we get to degrade Russia's military capabilities quote unquote without actually having to
26:10
expend any American blood just hundreds of billions of dollars of taxpayer money
26:16
so to your point about uh you know the Ukrainian government having been basically turned into a shell
26:22
that's controlled by whether it's the U.S military private corporations like palantir depending on
26:29
Elon Musk or the you know us and EU feasting off it uh like vultures on
26:38
behalf of Corp corporations in Wall Street here's a perfect example of that
26:43
here's Tony blinken appointing Penny pritzker as the U.S Special representative for Ukraine's economic
26:49
recovery she will work with Ukraine's government International Partners in the private sector to accelerate Ukraine's
26:56
economic transformation I can't think of anyone who better exemplifies the
27:03
exploitative predatory nature of the economic relationship between the
27:10
US and Ukraine than Penny pritzker who's got this phony position now to basically
27:16
bring U.S corporations in to strip what's left of Ukrainian public assets off under the cover of War penny
27:24
pritzker is from the notorious pritzker clan of Chicago which founded the Hyatt
27:29
Corporation with money from organized crime and stashed that money in an
27:35
offshore bank that had been set up by the oss the Forerunner to the CIA and
27:41
was also being used to wash Meyer Lansky's money while he was operating in
27:48
Cuba when that story was exposed in the Kansas City Star and I think 1982
27:54
Penny pritzker's father attempted to purchase the newspaper in order to
28:00
disappear that story from existence Penny pritzker herself as I pointed out
28:07
here was placed on the board of her family's Superior Bank which they bought with
28:13
government money are taxpayer money 625 billion dollars of it and then ran the
28:18
bank into the ground through a subprime mortgage scheme which left over 1400 uninsured depositors penniless they lost
28:27
all their savings and there was nothing they could do while the pritzker family
28:32
uh got wealthier and wealthier Penny pritzker was basically given over 50
28:38
million dollars from her family trust to just spend as she wished in 2008 when
28:45
she came up for uh as a nominee for uh kind of thing Commerce secretary under Obama she had to withdraw our nomination
28:52
because she couldn't handle questions about this but he eventually got her in there because you know she's basically
28:58
at the top of the democratic party Chicago machine her brother I think it's
29:03
her brother JB is the governor of Illinois he's a fairly Progressive governor
29:11
um you know there's there's a lot to say about the pritzker family but it's very very revealing that this special
29:19
position has been created by the state department for Penny pritzker to preside
29:24
over what's left of Ukraine's economy as I say Slava Wall Street
29:30
so well she I mean what is that position going to be basically just kind of an Auctioneer for BlackRock exactly
29:37
snatching up little bits of Industries uh desirable territories and then selling them off uh not even to the
29:45
highest bidder because you know I don't even get the sense that there's really a real competition going on it's just a
29:52
handful of companies that are all owned by the same company uh you know
29:57
snatching up whatever they can for as cheap as possible
30:02
yeah um it's very similar to
30:09
the the relationship between the US and Ukraine in in many ways is similar to the U.S
30:15
relationship with another country that's been destroyed by War but it was destroyed by a direct U.S
30:23
intervention and that of was done under the watch of Barack Obama
30:31
and that's Libya yeah so here here's Barack Obama commenting
30:37
on the natural disaster which is actually a man-made disaster in Libya where in the city of Darna
30:46
dams burst causing floods which killed 5 000 people and
30:52
it is a unbelievable disaster upon many disasters which Libya has experienced I
31:00
was actually listening to an interview with the former information Minister under the
31:09
deposed and destroyed government of former Libyan president murdered Libyan president Muammar Gaddafi on RT
31:17
the information Minister said that those dams in derna were up for inspection in
31:23
2012 but the country was split in half thanks to NATO's intervention in 2011 so
31:29
they never got inspected so here's Barack Obama here's this one tweet on Libya
31:36
if you're looking to help people impacted by the floods in Libya check out these organizations providing relief
31:42
and then it goes to the Obama Foundation which is recommending that people donate
31:48
to the Red Cross and Oxfam and um you know a bunch of basically the
31:54
development industry that's cashing going to cash in on Libya's disaster and
32:00
much of the money probably most of the money with the Red Cross will go to administrative costs and in other words
32:05
paying paper pushing staff so this is disgusting Barack Obama comes in destroys a country
32:13
and then he just says check out these organizations that are helping and I'm going to go have dinner with Steven Spielberg and Bruce Springsteen after uh
32:20
the boss's concert Michelle's going to play tambourine let me be clear I enjoy cooking in Martha's Vineyard
32:30
my chef had uh very good swimming lessons
32:36
here's a good swimmer and uh check out myself check out these
32:42
organizations but this is the this is the response from mainstream media and all of the major officials who
32:49
participated intimately in the destruction of Libya which led you could which where you can draw a straight line
32:57
between This Disaster and the intervention
33:02
uh Samantha power was one of the key figures Who convinced Obama actually
33:10
Obama knows that it was a disaster he was upset about it and he actually was
33:18
in many ways blaming Samantha power in the media afterwards for what he called the biggest mistake of his
33:23
administration here's Samantha power the because the flooding has killed a lot of people so usaid she's this you know
33:30
director general of usaid now uh just deployed a Disaster Assistance
33:35
Response Team oh it's giving him one million dollars one million dollars thanks a lot
33:41
thanks for nothing like a million bucks how much did it cost to destroy Libya probably a lot
33:47
more and how much damage did it cause to Libya hundreds of billions of dollars
33:52
and so as I and you yeah go ahead Samantha power afterwards
34:00
yeah I mean her quote after the war when she was challenged about it was we could hardly expect to have a crystal ball
34:06
when it came to accurately predicting outcomes in places where the culture was not our own I mean what better
34:13
distillation of the colonial mindset of the usaid the responsibility to protect
34:19
liberal interventionists who destroyed Libya and the whole development industry the aid industry that's now coming to
34:25
Libya could there be than that we didn't know when we wanted to destroy the government of this country what was
34:30
going to happen because it was a different culture but we did it anyway and hey some people we tortured some it's like
34:36
Obama's saying we tortured some folks well and that's that quote came from her new book or well a book yeah three four
34:44
years ago and I actually had the chance to challenge her on this I went to her book signing and I made the fatal error
34:51
of not purchasing a book and you know that I would have had a chance to uh talk to her a little bit longer but I
34:58
got up in her in her face and I recorded it and I said well uh you know you I I
35:04
now notice that in your book you said we could hardly expect to have a crystal ball when it came to accurately
35:10
predicting outcomes uh did you have a crystal ball for Syria right did you
35:16
learn your lesson after Libya did you get acquire this new magical crystal ball and you know did you decide to
35:22
apply that those lessons to Syria of course she didn't refuse to answer my
35:27
questions she called security uh security tried to chase me out of the building uh they missed me on the
35:33
elevator and I saw them running their way up the stairs as I was walking out uh but uh yeah probably faster than any
35:41
of those security guards that ever run in their lives um you know
35:46
heaven heaven forbid a politician in DC faced one single moment of uh you know
35:53
skeptical questioning um and that was that was right before covet happened you know that was one of
35:59
the last chances that I got to actually kind of uh Stick it to any of these people and and just ask them the
36:06
questions that the mainstream media the Legacy Media would ask them if they were
36:11
made up of anything more than corporate stenographers uh but then of course covet happened all of these things
36:17
became remote uh and ever since it's been basically impossible to talk to any
36:22
of these people and to kind of get them on the record ask them these uncomfortable questions
36:29
um and uh you know I I uh I kind of wish it it was still possible I I certainly
36:35
would have much more of a desire to live in Washington DC if it was
36:43
well it is increasingly possible but there were years when it it wasn't uh
36:48
and that was pretty frustrating for me but sometimes you just gotta bum rush the show like I did when Rachel Maddow
36:54
was speaking uh because they don't want to take questions anyway even if they're in person and we saw Samantha power at
37:01
this big rollout for the state and a smartphone Dia app she wasn't going to take any questions here's the BBC on
37:08
Libya's disaster completely context-free tweet I guess there aren't any Community
37:14
notes on it Libya was once one of Africa's most prosperous countries but years of lawlessness have left it in
37:20
a fragile divided state ill-prepared to cope with the forces Unleashed by a natural disaster I wonder what could
37:27
have contributed to the forces of lawlessness I wonder what that could have been
37:33
well the the problem is there there was I believe a community note uh on this on
37:39
this uh on this tweet uh explaining just that I'm trying to pull it up I I'm not
37:46
seeing it anywhere I believe it was the second time that uh this
37:53
the you know some kind of anti-nato critical uh
37:58
uh note was uh posted and then very quickly uh unposted uh the same thing
38:07
happened last month when uh NATO made a post describing uh their supposed
38:15
defensive orientation uh last month uh they uh and we've got
38:23
this here in the document uh they made this extremely bizarre post
38:28
saying quote let's get our fats straight NATO is a defensive Alliance aiming to
38:34
safeguard its member nations and I totally destroyed them they got ratio to
38:40
Hell uh I posted some photos
38:45
yeah and uh in former Yugoslavia this is what Belgrade looked like after NATO
38:51
defensively bombed it for 78 days killing over 2 000 civilians and
38:58
uh here well this originally prompted a a
39:03
community note which explained that uh NATO is not a defensive Alliance it said
39:09
that NATO quote NATO assured Soviet leaders not to expand Eastward one inch it's well
39:16
documented they cited NSA archive documents which prove exactly that and
39:22
then the same note Community note said that NATO also conducted several Wars and operations as a great as aggressor
39:29
like in Yugoslavia and Libya but within hours this community note was deleted
39:36
I'm sure after some frantic incredulous calls between some NATO uh operative and
39:44
the community notes uh staff someone at Twitter someone at Big Tech and that
39:50
note was removed and then shortly thereafter it was replaced with another one that said quote whilst the number of
39:58
the was the number of Civilian death toll is concerning you like that construction like clearly some idiot
40:05
pretending to be smart misspelled death toll and they threw in wilst you know a
40:10
sure sign of somebody trying to sound smarter than they are whilst the number of Civilian death toll is concerning a
40:17
realistic assessment would place the number at around 488 to 527 according to
40:23
Human Rights Watch the 2000 death toll figure comes from the Yugoslav government a number which
40:30
hasn't been verified yeah so it's like uh it's just it's you know NATO and it's
40:36
I don't know if it's bot army or whatever impressed upon X the need to decontextualize your Tweet
40:45
and whitewash their reputation that they're putting forward as a defensive alliance against obviously against the
40:52
wishes of the consensus which it was responsible for the original Community note and this happened this is
40:57
increasingly happening as uh we see the attempts to bring Elon Musk to heal
41:03
so it's depressing but back to back to Libya I mean there's an obvious effort
41:10
right now to whitewash a deliberate effort to whitewash the context out of
41:17
the discussion for one of the worst natural disasters this year across the
41:22
globe because it wasn't a natural disaster it was an unnatural disaster and people like Samantha power should be
41:29
held accountable for it people like Barack Obama should be held accountable for it and they're still holding
41:34
government positions it's remarkable what we're seeing from I mean even the
41:40
Washington Post well here's here's the BBC's security correspondent who's a
41:46
complete stenographer for the British National Security State Frank Gardner he wrote
41:51
that the crisis has been compounded by Libya's dysfunctional politics
41:57
in the country lacking the security and stability that its people crave no mention of 2011. then then the chief
42:06
Middle East you know how those people are yeah they just crave security but
42:12
they're people are just wild Savages together it wasn't like they were there you know yeah exactly it's just a
42:18
dysfunctional bunch of brown people they just it's not as though they had the most prosperous stable country and a
42:25
completely stable country on the African continent prior to 2011.
42:30
uh and then Quentin Somerville the Middle East correspondent for BBC comes in this is a radio report so
42:37
um I'm just reading it there are many countries that could have handled flooding on this scale I wonder why but
42:43
not one as troubled as Libya it has had a long and painful decade Civil Wars local conflicts and Dern itself was
42:50
taken over by ISIS the city was bombed to remove them from there so Civil Wars and local conflicts it doesn't mention
42:57
regime change Wars or that the British State actually armed
43:02
one group after spawning a Civil War the Libyan Islamic fighting group
43:09
who trained Salman abedi who then went into Syria to fight with ISIS
43:16
and that the Royal Navy then gave Salman abedi and his father who fought with the Libyan Islamic
43:22
fighting group of literal a ride from Libya back to the UK on a royal Navy ship
43:29
back to Manchester UK where the MI6 ran a ring of Libyan Islam of Libyan Exiles
43:37
anti-qadhafi Exiles and Salman abedi proceeded to use the training he received from the lifg which is an
43:44
Al-Qaeda Ally in Libya and Isis to carry out the worst terror attack in British
43:50
history killing dozens and dozens of girls
43:55
at an Ariana Grande concert Grande concert
44:02
and that that episode was also deliberately decontextualized
44:09
the overrunning of jihadist Bandits through the Sahel region from through
44:15
Northern Mali all the way to Burkina Faso as a result of the Libyan disaster
44:23
has been whitewashed out of history now as one government after another Falls to
44:29
military juntas responding to the public call for security
44:34
this is it's so it's very frustrating to watch this and I think accountability there's still
44:41
why what you tried to do uh with Samantha power and we need to continue
44:46
to do that to try to hold them accountable in public for this vast crime
44:53
um and it's the kind of thing that uh journalists refuse to do the Washington
44:59
Post has a headline it's everyone is to blame for Libya I mean this one at least by ishan tarore who is a complete tool
45:06
who is like supporting the Syria regime change operation and is their foreign policy kind of wonk it at least mentions
45:14
the Libyan regime change war in the beginning but the headline is designed to just
45:19
dilute the conversation and it makes everyone dumb that's why
45:25
everyone in Washington is so dumb because they don't want they don't want anyone to know that they don't want
45:31
anyone to read history well only 400 people died in Yugoslavia
45:37
it was okay it was good we didn't use depleted uranium in belgrad we didn't bomb the national TV
45:45
station and kill makeup artists it was just a few hundred people according to
45:51
um our new community note I mean
45:56
we don't need a Human Rights Watch one of the most notorious you know uh NGO
46:03
industrial complex leaders uh which receives over 100 million dollars from
46:08
the open Society Foundation from George Soros uh Human Rights Watch yeah one of
46:14
one of the worst when it comes to supposed human rights organizations uh
46:20
you know that's an acceptable Source the Yugoslav government what would they know you know how could they possibly know
46:27
human well Human Rights Watch was run by Ken Roth who he was an open supporter
46:32
of that military intervention Ken Roth was an open supporter of military intervention in Libya Ken Roth was an
46:40
open supporter of regime change war in Syria Ken Roth was an open supporter of the coup in Bolivia and he's running a
46:47
human rights organization and he's going and hanging out at the state department
46:52
under Obama and you know who else supported all these in writing at the New York Review of Books which he funds
46:58
George Soros he called for direct military intervention in Syria in the New York
47:04
Review of Books so it's not like some George Soros conspiracy that he wanted to topple these countries with his money
47:10
and was using his Empire of influence to do so it might be an anti-semitic stereotype
47:16
for a guy to try to do that it's definitely evil but it's on the record
47:23
um yeah right if he doesn't want to play into you know anti-semitic stereotypes
47:29
then he should perhaps not try to rule the world with his money and influence and get rid of every government he
47:36
doesn't like by force of necessary yeah I mean I believe you know we are a
47:42
chosen people we're chosen to be good so if you don't want to be good we're not chosen to take over some you know
47:49
take to take control or chosen to be or uh you know
47:54
above anyone else and I don't think anyone believes that but maybe anti-semites do but I think you know you
48:00
have a responsibility to represent and George Soros like Sheldon Adelson
48:06
has chosen to be one of the to to basically be the manifestation of an
48:13
anti-semitic stereotype uh and why is it not disgusting to
48:19
people who all these you know there's a lot of writing about George Soros now because
48:25
he's handing over his Empire to his son Alex and so there's a lot of coverage in mainstream media of George soros's
48:32
Legacy why is it not disgusting to people that someone who obtained vast wealth through parasitic Financial
48:40
practices is able to actually decide who comes into power in governments around the
48:46
world through an Empire of influence why is that not upsetting to people why is it just brushed off as an anti-semitic
48:52
conspiracy because he is operating as David Ignatius wrote In 1991 in the
48:58
Washington Post as an overt operator of U.S intelligence he's doing what they
49:03
want the moment he stops as Elon Musk did with Crimea and starlink then he'll
49:09
become the official enemy and then they'll start deploying the same rhetoric that they denounced before as
49:16
anti-semitic against him but George Soros has always played ball because it advances what does he want he just wants
49:23
global capitalism because that's how he got rich that's the open Society he wants global capitalism with you know
49:29
gay pride parades and what what it comes down to is you know the
49:36
idea that criticizing him is inherently anti-semitic it's kind of this new weaponization of identity of identity
49:43
politics uh the deployment of specific people in specific areas to be able to
49:50
deflect any legitimate criticism as somehow racist or sexist or in the case
49:57
of uh the next person I was wanting to discuss uh transphobic uh Sarah late
50:03
transition great transition wise right well uh that's all everybody's
50:11
been talking about today here in uh in Moscow at least uh is this insane video
50:17
published by Sarah Ashton Cirillo the new uh spokesperson of the Ukrainian
50:24
military English spokesperson absolutely right uh just absolutely unhinged uh
50:31
diatribe it's uh it's it's hard to believe it was real a lot of people a
50:37
lot of the anti-russian voices I was going to call them pro-ukrainian voices but they're not there's nothing
50:42
pro-ukrainian about sentencing hundreds of thousands of boys to die for a proxy war for black rocks profits uh these
50:50
anti-russian NATO trolls and all these uh people on social media were spending
50:56
the better part of the day insisting that this video is fake that it was somehow a Russian deep fake
51:02
um and that actually respond to a a further video from Sarah Ashton cerullo
51:08
and uh this person insisted no this is real uh this is absolutely real uh
51:15
attempted to clarify that they weren't necessarily talking about hunting down uh Russians in the streets but uh let's
51:22
take a look at this video it's because it's just uh it's almost beyond belief
51:27
how rabid it is yeah I mean I had named this stream
51:33
Goodbye Horses but I can't play the the song from one of the most famous
51:40
scenes of Silence of the Lambs because I can't layer it over this diatribe by
51:47
this Ukrainian military official spokesperson Sarah Ashton Cirillo
51:52
because uh it would violate YouTube terms of using licensed music and we
51:57
would be demonetized so just sing it in your head if you've seen Silence of the Lambs just kind of hum along as you
52:03
watch this Russia hates the truth that their obsessive focus on a Ukrainian volunteer is simply allowing the light
52:10
of the Ukrainian nation's honesty to shine brightly next week the teeth of the Russian
52:16
Devils will Nash ever harder and the Rabid mouths will foam in uncontrollable frenzy as the world will see a favorite
52:23
Gremlin propagandist hey for their crimes and this puppet of poo is only
52:29
the first Russia's war criminal propagandus will all be hunted down and
52:34
Justice will be served as we in Ukraine are LED on this Mission by faith in God
52:39
Liberty and complete liberation so they are calling
52:45
promising the murder of what they call a Kremlin propagandist and we're called Kremlin propagandists by our enemies so
52:53
it could just be anyone basically the murder of a journalist who doesn't report what they don't like and
52:58
promising that they will only be the first and there have been many already I mean they're killing media figures inside Russia left and
53:05
right literary figures Daria dugina was deliberately targeted in a Ukrainian sbu
53:11
operation and killed spokesperson
53:19
this is official yeah uh number number of journalists
53:24
have already been targeted killed uh Daria and in bombings right bombings in
53:30
civilian areas bombings and civilian buildings uh there's no other word for
53:36
it but terrorism uh and this obviously comes as president zielinski himself uh
53:44
has is threatening terrorism openly uh in an interview with the economist this
53:50
is uh uh really kind of a terror wave as as you
53:56
described it the the the idea here being and and I think it's worth pulling up
54:02
this this tweet you made so this is zielinsky in an interview uh about five
54:08
days ago with the with the economist curtailing Aid to Ukraine will only
54:14
prolong the war Mr zielinski argues and it would create risks for the West in its own backyard there's no way of
54:20
predicting how the millions of Ukrainian refugees and European countries would react to their country being abandoned
54:26
that's the words of the economist ukrainians have generally quote behaved well and are very grateful zielinski
54:33
says to those who sheltered them they will not forget that generosity but it would not be a quote good story for
54:40
Europe if it were to quote Drive these people into a corner so what could zolenski be implying the
54:49
same at around the same week that one of his top English prop language propagandists
54:57
is threatening or promising the assassination of journalists foreign
55:04
journalists well let's break this down right because what this means is we're going to take
55:11
all these billions hundreds of billions uh on weapons right training funding and
55:18
what we're going to do is openly threaten to use it against you if you don't give us more this is the same
55:24
thing that Al Qaeda did that the mujahideen did and then Osama Bin Laden
55:30
decided he'd been betrayed by the West which didn't want to fund him anymore you no longer became useful once uh
55:38
Afghanistan succeeded right this this mujahideen in Afghanistan succeeded they
55:43
managed to use it to bring down the Soviet Union it was no longer useful the
55:48
funding and the arms dried up and who did he turn his sights on right so this is it's the same exact
55:55
thing um and I would say you know that these people don't learn their lessons but I think that's being too charitable they
56:01
know exactly what they're doing uh this is all kind of part of the plan right and then and then we'll have
56:07
justification for the next war on terror right then we can continue to have a reason to spend all of our money
56:14
combating Terror instead of uh building any infrastructure uh doing anything for
56:20
the masses of homeless people that now populate every major Metropolitan Center in the United States uh you know
56:27
providing any resources for people at home uh you know all of that is is going
56:34
to be off the table for the foreseeable future once we have this Terror wave that zielinski is now threatening us
56:40
with if we don't give him what he wants yeah and we've written before about uh Italian
56:47
police breaking up as of related plots by returning Fighters uh to blow up
56:54
police facilities and terrorize the country we've written about American
56:59
foreign Fighters um basically hiding like Craig Lang from murder charges in the U.S these are
57:07
hardcore white supremacists but nazolensky is referring to the entire
57:12
mass of Ukrainian refugees in order to threaten and intimidate the
57:19
west and to continue to provide him with Advanced military systems weapon systems it also kind of reminds me of erdogan
57:27
exploiting Syrian refugees and unleashing them into Europe every time
57:32
he fails to get what he wants in negotiations uh basically using masses
57:37
of people as a negotiating tool really shows the cynicism of the government in
57:43
Kiev and well the the aid is going to
57:49
the aid is going to decrease Tony blinken was in Kiev to basically
57:55
tell zelenski that the political headwinds in Washington and in the U.S are too intense
58:02
to continue to provide Aid at the same level I think Angelina bareback the German foreign minister was there for
58:07
the same reason and they're trying to Edge him into some kind of negotiations I don't see why
58:13
Russia would enter into them now given their success on the battlefield that's the situation diplomatically that
58:20
Lincoln created by stifling a ceasefire and stifling negotiations throughout 2022
58:26
uh but now zolenski's threatening a terror wave across Europe and Europe of course is going to Bear the brunt what
58:31
what does Washington care it's not going to happen here how many Ukrainian refugees have we taken in here how many Syrian refugees do we take in here
58:38
Europe always has to Bear the Brunt Germany took in one million Syrian refugees
58:45
the U.S took in what sixty thousand fifty thousand I mean the U.S drives all of these
58:52
insane proxy wars and then it destabilizes Europe and who benefits in Europe I mean this was the main thesis
58:58
of my 2019 book the management of savagery the right wing
59:03
that and then the U.S says oh democracy is under threat brexit it's your fault and it's the fault specifically of the
59:09
liberal interventionists the Samantha Powers the Hillary Clinton's the The Joe coxes in the UK
59:16
um the Hillary bends The Cure starmers it's
59:21
their fault so back to Sarah Ashton Cirillo
59:27
Wyatt they yeah formerly known as Michael Cirillo a democratic very shady
59:35
Democratic operative from Las Vegas whose real story has yet to be
59:41
fully told I don't know I mean there's so there's there's a wild story there how they wound up being a democratic
59:48
operative in Las Vegas uh trapping proud boys
59:53
through various unusual schemes into committing illicit acts that got them
59:59
jailed or whatever into becoming an official spokesperson for the Ukrainian military without even
1:00:06
speaking Russian or Ukrainian how that happened is an unusual story
1:00:11
um I mean I guess I don't know to illustrate the in the weirdness of this
1:00:17
Saga and sorry but any normal P person will see this is is just extremely weird and
1:00:23
not take seriously uh and not take this person seriously
1:00:29
except as a if a a repulsive reflection
1:00:37
of the Ukrainian militaries presentation of the world this was Sarah Ashton Cirillo as Michael
1:00:44
Cirillo when they were a democratic operative and liberal activist in Nevada just a few years ago like not long ago
1:00:52
I'm going to be leaving to the United States I've been here in Europe for six weeks checked in on video several times
1:00:58
and this afternoon here in Frankfurt I had the opportunity to visit the Frankfurt book fair which is a
1:01:05
tremendous International exhibition of Publishers and authors writers and other ancillary parts of the writing industry
1:01:13
but the most important thing I found was this little postcard and in German it says
1:01:20
and right below it it reads hashtag free the words it's a movement against
1:01:26
censorship a censorship movement against censorship Europe and plaguing a lot of the nation-states that uh are found
1:01:33
across the globe and so I'm hoping to put up this video and if anybody sees it remember
1:01:39
don't be afraid to speak your mind and with words comes for freedom thank you rewards comes Freedom how
1:01:46
ironic and so when Sarah action chirilla was a man named Michael Cirillo uh who
1:01:53
seemed very comfortable about being a man not very long ago before they took on an entirely new identity
1:02:00
they were denouncing censorship and now Sarah Ashton Cirillo the
1:02:06
transgender spokesperson for the Ukrainian military has put you on a new list Wyatt uh and
1:02:14
you know I was calling for you to be silenced and they're calling for the killing of journalists with no
1:02:21
denunciation from the U.S nothing from the committee to protect journalists or any International NGO in condemnation uh
1:02:28
what's going on there Wyatt well it was not actually Sarah Ashton
1:02:34
cirilla who created this list this was originally published by Ukraine's Ambassador for strategic Communications
1:02:41
a man named Olex Sherba um but I real quick before we get into
1:02:47
that I did want to add in terms of what you you were describing as kind of this
1:02:53
um this blowback of uh U.S policy um and and and you mentioned that why
1:03:00
would Russia want to negotiate um because of course at this point they
1:03:05
wouldn't right and they would see the fact that the United States is now willing to negotiate is basically a
1:03:10
concession that things are not going the way the West wanted them to um basically this the same way that the
1:03:18
West imposed sanctions on Russia they predicted that they would turn the ruble into Rubble uh that didn't happen uh if
1:03:26
anything it it allowed Russia to strengthen then it's domestic
1:03:33
economic base all the companies that that left McDonald's and Starbucks they
1:03:41
left these massive operations more or less intact which then Russian business
1:03:46
people were able to take over very quickly have all the employees
1:03:53
already trained on how to make everything on how to run these businesses they basically just handed
1:03:58
the keys over to Russian Russian entrepreneurs the same thing is
1:04:05
basically happening on the military front right we had Lloyd Austin predicting back in April of 2022 or
1:04:13
rather explaining in April 2022 that quote we want to see Russia weakened to
1:04:18
the degree that it can't do the things it has done in invading Ukraine right so
1:04:23
that was the admission very very straightforwardly not that this has anything to do with democracy which of
1:04:29
course doesn't exist in Ukraine which is now under martial law uh which has no plans to hold elections zelenski has
1:04:36
said that he won't even think about holding elections unless he gets 5 billion from the West
1:04:42
um but the point was rather to weaken Russia and what has happened instead
1:04:47
well now Russia is weakening NATO Russia is effectively demilitarized Ukraine and
1:04:53
destroyed all of its equipment and is now destroying all of the NATO equipment that is going to that has been getting
1:04:58
shipped in all of the well tanks the leper tanks well plenty of it right
1:05:04
enough that it is clearly impacted a number of Western countries military Readiness and their ability to to fight
1:05:11
uh so to me it's it's kind of it's it's just it's Looney Tunes level uh Wiley
1:05:19
Coyote kind of tactics where the Roadrunner just keeps just keeps you know blowing up uh Wiley Coyote who no
1:05:26
matter what he wants to do just can't seem to do anything right but getting back to this uh Sarah Ashton Cirillo
1:05:34
story uh yeah I've now been placed on yet another list uh for the crime of
1:05:42
witnessing elections um of traveling to territory that Ukraine claims as its own uh despite
1:05:50
widespread sentiment among the people who live there to the contrary uh the I
1:05:56
I witnessed uh elections as they were being held in uh zaparosa and for this
1:06:03
crime I have been added to another list this one produced by an organization
1:06:10
called Democratic Integrity I've been placed on a handful of other lists and
1:06:15
another uh Ukrainian hit piece attacking me as well uh basically calling me uh
1:06:22
you a vulture uh this this original tweet by Alexander Sherba the Ambassador
1:06:29
for strategic Communications at Ukraine's Ministry of Foreign Affairs the former Ukrainian ambassador to
1:06:36
Austria says the list of international observers in scare quotes who came to
1:06:41
occupy Ukraine to enable the occupation in genocide these aren't quote unquote
1:06:46
useful idiots these are vultures feeding on Ukraine's suffering another threat uh
1:06:52
this one a little bit more bailed this follows threats uh Threat by Anthony blinken himself of uh sanctions and
1:07:00
visual restrictions against anyone who served as an election Observer for these
1:07:07
elections or anyone really who came uh to these territories at all I myself was
1:07:13
placed on Ukraine's notorious uh Peacemaker kill list last year after I
1:07:19
went to Crimea within two days of making it to Russia I was placed on this list
1:07:26
uh that has had no uh dozens and dozens of people who have been placed on this
1:07:31
list have been killed and then subsequently marked liquidated over their face in Big Red Letters in
1:07:39
Ukrainian uh another obvious threat against my physical safety for my my
1:07:46
reporting and my coverage and my failure to toe the line in terms of what the
1:07:52
state Department's preferred regime in Kiev wants to have broadcast
1:07:59
and then within uh you know a couple weeks of that my hotel in Danette was struck just two
1:08:09
hours after I arrived with a 155 millimeter Nato standard artillery shell as I was returning from a restaurant I
1:08:16
was about 100 meters away uh I don't have any proof that they were necessarily targeting me it's entirely
1:08:23
plausible they were simply targeting this hotel the Don bass Palace that's known to host journalists and
1:08:30
international figures certainly uh no indication that I myself was personally
1:08:35
targeted but the fact of the matter is uh they are certainly targeting other
1:08:40
people on this list there are a number of people who've been killed who've been placed on this list many of them many of
1:08:48
the people on this list are children I believe her name is uh Faina
1:08:53
um I'm blanking on her last name a 13 year old seven kova yeah so
1:09:00
plenty of people here have have real reason to worry for their personal
1:09:06
physical integrity and uh you know at this point it's it's just another list to add to the lists that they've listed
1:09:12
me on well uh
1:09:18
stay safe out there Wyatt I don't know uh but but but I think the
1:09:23
important thing is that to not be intimidated we're not intimidated we're not going to be
1:09:29
intimidated by some freak Show uh threatening to kill everybody
1:09:34
uh I think what what we need to do again is hold the U.S government accountable
1:09:42
this is because this is a U.S government War the US government's paying for U.S
1:09:49
citizen Cirillo to be barking out these bizarre serial
1:09:55
killer Level Threats against journalists
1:10:01
and so they need to be called out onto the mat for that for sponsoring
1:10:07
everything the Ukrainian government does and every NGO needs to be called up and
1:10:15
asked and anyone who's watching this can do it you can call and email Human Rights Watch the committee to protect
1:10:21
journalists Amnesty International the freedom of the press foundation and ask what they think about this U.S backed
1:10:29
U.S citizen in Kiev calling for the mass murder of journalists who don't
1:10:36
basically don't say what the Ukrainian government wants and the targeting of
1:10:41
Wyatt read right here none of them have said a word not one word
1:10:47
so white I know you have to go I don't know if there's anything you want to add yeah I will just say
1:10:55
this is a point I've made many times no no one in the western media aside from
1:11:00
useful idiots Katie Halper uh Aaron mate
1:11:06
no one in the U.S media said a damn word about me getting added to this list
1:11:11
about my hotel being struck I was told that I was going to be reached out to by
1:11:18
someone at The Intercept that of course never happened uh it's not convenient to report this stuff uh it's it it just
1:11:27
just goes against the narrative it makes it makes it too clear that what we are
1:11:33
pursuing Ukraine has nothing to do with democracy or human rights or liberal values in the slightest
1:11:38
um and I will just say under I I added another link to this because I this is an another list that I found myself
1:11:45
added on to uh this one called fakeobservers.org which is run by the
1:11:51
European platform for Democratic elections entirely funded or almost entirely funded by the European Union
1:11:57
and the German government um it's filled with inaccuracies misinformation lies about me uh they
1:12:05
even misspell my name at one point uh they incorrectly claim that I work for Sputnik I do not work for Sputnik
1:12:11
anymore and then they claim that I worked for the gray Zone when I covered the referendums last year also not true
1:12:19
um but uh what it is is uh another example of basically our money in the
1:12:25
west being used to violate our own rights and prevent us from going out to
1:12:31
tell the truth about what's happening in the world uh the the mainstream media of
1:12:36
course could come and discuss what's happening they could send reporters to the Don
1:12:42
bass there are no restrictions against them they would be allowed in uh that's
1:12:48
what I've been told by by officials in these new territories uh it's just that
1:12:53
they choose not to despite having billion dollar budgets despite having more than enough resources to come uh to
1:12:59
cover this they choose instead to cover it up um and that's again why they are
1:13:06
threatening people uh with sanctions with visa restrictions it's why they
1:13:12
tried to freeze our GoFundMe it's why they have permanently Banned Me from PayPal and from venmo because they want
1:13:20
to prevent their people from knowing the truth they want to prevent our people
1:13:25
from knowing the truth so they punish anybody who actually tries to tell the
1:13:30
truth uh so that's where we are now it's it's a slippery slope it's gotten
1:13:37
increasingly dangerous in the past few years and I'm worried that with the
1:13:42
escalations the decision now to send attackum's missiles which seems to be on the horizon something that was dismissed
1:13:49
like the idea of sending f-16s as a needless escalation that could potentially bring us to the cusp of
1:13:55
World War III now all of that is on the table the gloves are off there's nothing
1:14:00
that they won't do to win re-election and to win this or or continue I should
1:14:08
say this proxy war with Russia so everything is fair game and it doesn't
1:14:15
matter how many ukrainians have to die it doesn't matter how many of our rights our basic fundamental rights they have
1:14:20
to violate it seems at this point they're willing to do anything
1:14:27
indeed whether they'll be able to is another story but the gloves are off
1:14:36
uh wyatta as I said I know you had to I know you have to go I'm going to just uh respond to one
1:14:42
super chat but thanks thanks for joining us this week and good luck out there
1:14:49
appreciate it take care guys all right you and maybe you'll get some
1:14:55
sleep in Kentucky sooner or later I will thanks Mike all
1:15:00
right peace all right so
1:15:07
I wanted to conclude but I I do want to address one Super Chat because it was something I wanted to talk about I'm not
1:15:12
really prepared with um all of the elements but this is uh Buckeye fan 05
1:15:19
care to comment on the recent developments of the Cornell West Camp and this is our reference I really wish
1:15:28
I had all the video elements here to illustrate some of the points I want to make I want to try to make it quick but
1:15:34
there's obviously a reference to Jimmy dore's interview with Cornell West in which Jimmy doors I mean it got very
1:15:40
testy and antagonistic and Jimmy Dore was challenging Cornell West's
1:15:47
his messaging around his presidential campaign and saying I don't know who's advising you here it seems like your
1:15:52
advisor is some kind of infiltrator because the messaging you're using is just no one understands what you're saying and it's going to only appeal to
1:15:59
a tiny slice of the electorate and it's going to alienate everyone else if you're just saying we need to stop Trump
1:16:06
the neo-fascist white supremacist uh and then kind of treating Biden with kid gloves and Jimmy
1:16:13
was predicting that he was going to basically endorse Biden and I think Jimmy's made some more
1:16:19
articulate points since the interview took place but it was such a reveal it was a very revealing look at Cornell
1:16:26
West as a presidential candidate I like Cornell personally he's been very encouraging in my work I
1:16:33
really like what he did at the tail end of the Obama era I think he what what he did in 2015 was extremely appropriate
1:16:41
just addressing how Barack Obama had failed Black America specifically but had sold out all of his 2008 promises
1:16:49
which I knew he was going to do and I really appreciate Cornell West uh calling out tanahisi coats this pet
1:16:57
project of the liberal establishment as their uh fake James Baldwin who was
1:17:03
going to represent himself as some kind of radical black intellectual while basically just being a hagiographer for
1:17:10
Obama who also was completely talentless and Cornell West showed that you know he
1:17:16
was the emperor had no clothes but the same thing can be done to Cornell West he needs to realize that if he's going
1:17:22
to run for president he has to be held accountable and this this needs to be
1:17:28
recognized about Jimmy Dore Jimmy Dore has held accountable everybody who's
1:17:33
running for president who has interviewed with him I think Jimmy is sympathetic to RFK Jr because of his
1:17:40
stance on the Ukraine war and on kovid those are two Jimmy's main issues but he
1:17:46
still held him accountable on Israel and brought me on and it kind of knocked the wind out of his sails at least with the
1:17:52
anti-war and anti-establishment left Jimmy didn't have to do that he held
1:17:58
Marion Williamson accountable on the Ukraine war and so he why is he supposed to give Cornell West a free pass when
1:18:04
Cornell West is using this very Arcane Boutique left language and speaking
1:18:10
purely in boilerplate I'm going to stand up against white supremacy and uh and
1:18:16
homophobia and male Supremacy and that's what a true revolutionary does and he's not offering any political program at
1:18:24
all at all I don't see anything and so I think it was entirely appropriate for
1:18:29
Jimmy to hold him to account and to force him to address
1:18:35
some of the kind of contradictions in his actions and his rhetoric
1:18:41
where Biden is president now and Cornell West doesn't seem to be running against Biden all of his rhetoric is directed
1:18:46
against much of his rhetoric or the disproportionate amount of it is directed against Trump
1:18:52
here's what I think was exposed through this exchange and I mean most people are
1:18:58
focusing on some rancorous
1:19:03
exchanges at the beginning but it's important to go towards the end where Jimmy uh Grill challenges Cornell West
1:19:12
on his view of the Trump indictments and of the whole campaign to basically
1:19:18
prevent Donald Trump from running for office and what Jimmy's talking about is what many people call the Deep State you
1:19:25
could call it the National Security State but it's basically
1:19:30
the rigging of democracy to prevent a candidate who's seen as a rogue in just
1:19:36
as Bernie Sanders in some ways was and as Cornell West would be if he actually was threatening The Establishment as a
1:19:42
presidential candidate using the law to prevent him from running for office just finessing all of these indictments and
1:19:49
then you know finessing indictments that sentence uh proud boys to over 20 years
1:19:55
in prison for riots that they didn't even participate in and Cornell West he said
1:20:02
well I'm in deep solidarity with the people in cop City who are getting hit with the RICO Act the way Trump is but
1:20:08
I'm not in deep solidarity with Donald Trump I'm not in deep solidarity with the proud boys so I don't care about
1:20:15
that and then he accuses Jimmy of supporting Trump because he he brings those issues up
1:20:22
and that's the problem with Cornell West's presidential campaign it's not about your deep solidarity it's about
1:20:30
it's about the system that we're living under and it will hurt the people that you're
1:20:35
in deep solidarity with but it's using the people that are more threatening to it at the current moment at this impasse
1:20:43
as in order to set a new standard for prosecuting protest and Cornell West
1:20:49
won't even address that because he because he's he he because they're white supremacists or transphobes or
1:20:55
homophobes right now you have such a huge opportunity in this country if you're an
1:21:01
anti-establishment independent candidate to reach out to people who just want to give the system a giant middle finger
1:21:08
because they see that it's been against them since they lost their homes during the Foreclosure crisis since
1:21:15
uh that they see it's against them because it's giving hundreds of billions of dollars to Ukraine and the people in
1:21:21
Hawaii got 700 bucks each they see that it's against them because their preferred candidate Donald Trump is
1:21:27
being targeted with lawfare and was falsely branded as a Russian agent for years and years with no evidence at all
1:21:35
so Cornell West is not running an anti-establishment campaign that can reach out to those people and actually
1:21:41
if he sees them as white supremacists or fascists well if they hear him and they say well wait a minute this guy's making
1:21:48
sense that would be building a bridge instead he's dismissing them all and only
1:21:54
addressing people with whom he's in deep solidarity which is a tiny group of Boutique left
1:22:01
activists in a blue area of the country uh
1:22:07
and so I said I said to Cornell directly that your rhetoric might be good for the
1:22:12
old brecht form which is a defunct activist space in New York but real serious
1:22:19
independent candidates like Ralph Nader for example in 2000 they made waves and threatened The Establishment by putting
1:22:25
together a real political program and it was based on class not all of the identitarian issues
1:22:32
obviously we can't discount identity uh for black Americans that's a huge
1:22:39
factor that but it's bound up in class but if you're running for president you should be running for president of
1:22:44
everyone and it's we're in it at a point a terminal phase of neoliberalism
1:22:51
where I think there's a huge opportunity for an independent candidate to actually build an anti-establishment Coalition
1:22:56
Cornell West wants to do is just keep this confined to the boutique left do
1:23:02
some virtue signaling and you know unfortunately I think he needs to be asked whether this is just about uh
1:23:09
you know a vanity project because of course the system's rigged so why would
1:23:14
anyone run for president except maybe for vanity that's a valid question he needs to be
1:23:20
asked that and so what he does his response and this this is you know the
1:23:25
question that I'm addressing here I'll just put the question of that back on on
1:23:30
screen care to comment on the recent developments of the Cornell West Camp his response has been to sick
1:23:38
sympathetic voices against Jimmy Dore uh to attack Jimmy Dore
1:23:44
first that's the first response to viciously attack Jimmy Dore
1:23:50
but when Anderson Cooper was much more condescending with Cornell West
1:23:55
or Ari melber criticized Cornell West for wanting to withdraw from NATO and they kind of
1:24:01
called him a kook did he send his supporters against them no he was like
1:24:09
brother Ari and brother uh Anderson he's been much more hostile to Jimmy Dore
1:24:14
because Jimmy Dore hit the he hit the nail on the head and
1:24:20
so Cornell West runs the risk now of becoming a caricature as a
1:24:27
presidential candidate whereas he had Consolidated his reputation as a academic and activist but he's in a
1:24:35
different realm now and Jimmy Dore is the one who threatens His Image by
1:24:41
actually asking serious questions about the contradictions in his messening
1:24:47
messaging and how he's out of touch another area where he's been out of touch is the the covet event the
1:24:53
pandemic Cornell West is never retracted his statement praising Anthony fauci as
1:24:59
some kind of heroic figure he refuses to address what the lockdowns
1:25:05
did to Black America specifically to Black public school students setting
1:25:10
them back for a generation by putting them in remote learning setting their families back to black women who were
1:25:16
forced to uh in some cases quit their jobs because they now had children at home who were
1:25:23
remote learning who could not go to school the threat that chill that and and the
1:25:30
insanity of the vaccine mandates throwing people out of their jobs for refusing to inject a substance in their
1:25:37
body that did not prevent infection or transmission he just won't go there so he's lost in 2015 like so much of the
1:25:45
left like so much of the boutique left their loss back in the Glory Days of the black lives matter before it became this
1:25:52
like uh Biden election project they're lost in 2015 they're lost in the
1:25:57
in the Glory Days of Bernie's 2016 campaign still feeding off the energy of
1:26:03
occupy and they don't want to address what's happened in the past three years with the pandemic and how that's changed
1:26:09
our politics and our society Washington DC homicides are up over 20
1:26:15
percent why is that that it doesn't have something to do with the societal deterioration and
1:26:23
destabilization of putting people out of work and out of their homes through Mass evictions of the lockdowns
1:26:31
he doesn't want to address that BlackRock seizing up property downtown D.C is a ghost town now since the
1:26:37
lockdowns in the pandemic it's not coming back what's what's coming to downtown DC is
1:26:44
Extreme poverty homelessness crime black rocks buying up distressed
1:26:50
commercial real estate he has no analysis of that and Jimmy Dore was calling him out where have you been
1:26:55
where are you why are you running for president we're in a different era this is in 2015
1:27:01
anymore why aren't you attacking Biden as hard
1:27:06
as you're attacking Donald Trump Biden's President Biden's got us in Ukraine
1:27:12
Biden sending weapons to Taiwan so it's completely valid and corn OS response has been that and to appoint
1:27:18
Peter Dao the guy who is attacking us all smearing
1:27:24
us all back in 2016 on behalf of Hillary's neoliberal campaign that
1:27:29
Cornell West had correctly refused to support after Bernie dropped
1:27:36
out also in 2020 refused to support it so you're bringing on this guy who's an obvious grifter Jimmy said your advisor
1:27:43
must be an infiltrator and Cornell West said well I don't have an advisor well now you do and he's an infiltrator and
1:27:48
he I don't know where the money is coming from to pay him but he's an infiltrator he's a clown he's a grifter
1:27:54
and uh I don't see any reason I I don't see why the green party uh did
1:28:03
this I mean Jill Stein I like her a lot respect what she did when she ran
1:28:12
um especially on foreign policy and they allow this guy to get in the
1:28:18
door Peter Dao to be the campaign manager
1:28:23
I mean this is ridiculous so it's it's also just generally depressing
1:28:29
I mean you look at the field of candidates who are the sort of posing as
1:28:34
anti-establishment Cornell West Marion Williamson RFK Jr they all have they all they all have
1:28:42
these huge glaring problems that almost make it impossible to
1:28:49
support them I mean I think rfk's support for the likud wing
1:28:56
of the Zionist movement for the Netanyahu government and the falsehoods
1:29:02
he deployed and the smears that he issued against all Palestinians
1:29:08
are a poison pill that cannot be swallowed Marion Williamson's support
1:29:14
for sending hundreds of billions of dollars to Ukraine sorry uh and you know
1:29:21
it's not as though she's the strongest Messenger on other issues and then you have Cornell West refusing to address
1:29:28
the pandemic brick sending people to bran Jimmy Dora racist for actually challenging him and sounding just kind
1:29:35
of out of touch with where most of the country is right now Cornell West the academic cornos the activist great job
1:29:43
you know we appreciate you but you're running for president so it's time for somebody
1:29:49
I mean if you're good I don't if you're going to run for president you should at least acknowledge that the whole thing
1:29:55
is rigged against you and that you have nothing to lose by actually challenging
1:30:00
The Establishment and not just some aspect of it unless you're running a vanity campaign for yourself
1:30:08
um so that's what I have to say about that hope that registered
1:30:14
I see we got a lot of live comments
1:30:20
um well I'll address one more
1:30:26
someone's saying you know it's nuts to take one thing RFK said about Israel and use and and
1:30:33
uh look at it as a contamination of his
1:30:39
entire campaign sorry Israel is a poison pill when you issue
1:30:46
unequivocal support to Israel as RFK did it it will poison everything else you seek to do and uh you're setting the
1:30:54
stage for regional war with Iran and that will destroy your presidency and it will destroy a large swath of the
1:31:01
planet so sorry you can't do that and his refusal to discuss this further
1:31:07
and just kind of moving along raises questions about why he did it in the first place why did he do that
1:31:14
shmueli event why did you get involved with people who are literal Ultra Zionist race Hustlers who are
1:31:21
always seeking some kind of transactional relationship with candidates
1:31:26
what's going on there what does that say about your integrity so right now
1:31:32
feels like a very hopeless moment for independent politics Nader was really
1:31:38
the high point I mean Ross Perot I don't support I didn't support him but he really showed how a rich guy can do
1:31:45
an independent campaign Ralph Nader showed how a an uh kind of public
1:31:51
Advocate can run a grassroots-based campaign and then you know he was destroyed
1:31:56
because this will be my final comment Ralph
1:32:02
Nader was destroyed because he's blamed for handing over was was blamed for uh
1:32:09
handing over the presidency to George W bush and then you know making the Iraq
1:32:15
War possible the whole Security State that grew out of the Patriot Act at the time I blamed him I was mad at Ralph
1:32:22
Nader I've had kind of a reassessment but you know Ralph Nader was never welcomed back into polite Society it's
1:32:29
because he ran in Florida you know Michael Moore is blaming that was not blaming him but begging him not
1:32:34
to run in Florida take your name off the ballot and then you had the whole Florida disaster and George W bush steals the election
1:32:42
and Jill Stein was then the next kind of major green candidate
1:32:48
to run um after some weaker runs by I think David Cobb Jill Stein kind of registered
1:32:54
and so they destroyed her over traveling to RT's 10th anniversary and they initiate the same forces that are
1:33:01
seeking to jail Donald Trump um brought her before the Senate
1:33:07
intelligence committee and initiated like an Espionage investigation against Jill Stein and that severely weakened the green
1:33:14
party led to the NATO neocon tool Howie Hawkins taking over for a while Howie
1:33:22
Hawkins supported regime change in Syria the Ukraine proxy war and uh Cornell West has come over from
1:33:29
the People's Party in a weird way and I just spent the last 20 minutes
1:33:35
addressing why his campaign is weak and why the other campaigns are weak but they've been weakened systematically
1:33:40
since Nader's run because of the threat they present to the Democratic party by the same forces that are trying to keep
1:33:46
Trump off the ballot so right now we have a situation where the neo-liberal establishment and the
1:33:54
United States as a global power in a unipolar world are weaker
1:34:01
than at any point since the end of the Cold War which
1:34:06
should create space for independent candidates which should Propel independent
1:34:12
candidates involve them into the mainstream because of the amount of discontent radical discontent among the
1:34:19
American masses the Betrayed American worker but we have a weaker field of
1:34:25
independent candidates as a result partly of the threat that independent
1:34:31
politics presents in the U.S and the systematic campaign to weaken it so here we here we have uh some very flawed
1:34:37
candidates RFK I don't know if he suggested he's going to run as an independent we'll see what happens there
1:34:43
but uh it's it's a it's a very dispiriting
1:34:48
moment and I think whatever you think of whatever your problems with Jimmy Dora might be he you
1:34:55
should owe it to him for at least holding accountable every candidate who agrees to interview with them
1:35:02
and exposing their contradictions the voter deserves that voters deserve
1:35:07
that and of course he would do that with major candidates but they won't get anywhere near him so that's what I have
1:35:12
to say about that thanks for joining us uh thanks for getting us to 300 000 YouTube subscribers like this stream
1:35:18
subscribe if you can sign up for our newsletter at the grayzone.com you can listen to
1:35:25
all sorts of content at my podcasts just look up Max
1:35:30
Blumenthal on Spotify or iTunes or whatever wherever podcasts are thanks to
1:35:37
Chris Weaver for all of his help in producing and thanks to Wyatt again for joining us
1:35:43
and we'll be back next week peace
Goodbye Horses - The Grayzone live
The Grayzone
300K subscribers
54,426 views  Streamed live on Sep 15, 2023
Max Blumenthal and Wyatt Reed discuss threats from Ukrainian officials to assassinate journalists and unleash a terror wave as Senate Democrats demand a probe into Elon Musk for refusing to participating in a Pearl Harbor style attack on Russia. They will also cover the hypocrisy around calls for Libya aid.
Transcript

Follow along using the transcript.
The Grayzone
300K subscribers

donderdag 6 juli 2023

GENDER ALCHEMY – The History of Today – w/ APOSTOLIC MAJESTY




-7/7 ------------------- 13Warrior ---- k156 -- 12/13 : : [LOT] --- 21/7 : [CTC]

 GENDER ALCHEMY – The History of Today – w/ APOSTOLIC MAJESTY
Semiogogue
15.8K subscribers
840 views  Streamed live 4 hours ago
Subscribe to Apostolic Majesty's Channel:
   / @apostolicmajesty  

Vinculum (Science Fiction) ::: https://tinyurl.com/y3jtfsh7
Cinders From The Bloomery of Youth (Poetry) https://tinyurl.com/2p2atnw9

good effort at ringin that 'sexhaultive' satiety pointbell from multiple angles at once but i am missing something along the lines of looking for exaclty what metastatic factors limit and end which of the one after the other circularity rite kwik ........ fertility / roots / fem ::::: sterilogix / [d]escape / autist ralley pallee stroumbles ... iow, ... the contrast / complement set:
industrial toxicity driven trannicization
 ['wht {{{greenwash}}} do we want, when do we want it ]
................ also drives the euthenization mov[i]es

dinsdag 11 april 2023

Ep212.1 Mark on DARPA 2nd to none

Ep 212.1: Was DARPA's ADEPT mimicked by USAMRIID in 2016 to jump-start CEPI for the W.H.O. ?

7.05K subscribers

vrijdag 10 maart 2023

Kolam: What The Hand Said | Anil Menon

Kolam: What The Hand Said | Anil Menon: Kolams are curvilinear shapes drawn by Tamil women, usually early in the morning and usually just outside the house. Kolams have fascinating relationships with the labyrinths of Crete, sona drawings of the Chockwe and picture grammars.

 

 

took about 7 tries to be able to copy all shareways:

    twitter
    facebook
    gplus
    rss

Share
Kolam: What The Hand Said | Anil Menonhttps://anilmenon.com/kolam-what-the-hand-said/
Top Services

FacebookTwitterPrintEmailPinterestGmailLinkedInEmail AppTumblr

    Messenger

100zakladokAdftyAdifniADV QRAmazonAmen Me!AOL LifestreamAOL MailAPSenseAtaviBaiduBalatarinBeat100Bit.lyBizSugarBland takkinnBloggerBlogmarksBobrdobrBonzoBoxBookmarky.czBookmerkenBoxBufferCamyooCare2CiteULikeCommunicateCopy LinkCOSMiQCSS BasedDiary.ruDiggDiggitaDiigoDoubanDraugiem.lvEdCastEvernoteExchangleFabDesignFacenamaFai InformazioneFancyFashiolistaFAVableFavoritesFavoritusFinancial JuiceFlipboardFolkdFreeDictionaryGGGo.vnGoogle BookmarkGoogle ClassroomGoogle TranslateHacker NewsHatenaHedgehogshistoriousHootsuiteHouzzHTML ValidatorIndexorInstapaperiOrbixJappy TickerKaixin RepasteKakaoKakao TalkKetnooiKindle ItKledyLiDAR OnlineLINELinkuj.czLiveJournalMail.rumar.gar.inMarkmemeinVZMemonicMendeleyMeneameMIXMixiMoemesto.ruMore...mRcNEtwORKMyspacemyVidsterN4GNasza-klasaNetvibesNetvouzNewsvineNujijNurses LoungeOdnoklassnikiOKNOtizieOneNoteOpenTheDoorOutlookOyylapafnet.dePDFmyURLPinboardPlurkPocketPosteezyPrintFriendlyPushaQRSrc.comQuantcastQzoneRedditRediff MyPageRenrenResearchGateSafelinkingScoop.itSettings...Sina WeiboSkypeSkyrock BlogSlackSMSSodaHeadSpinSnapStartaidStartlapstudiVZStuffpitStumpediaSurfingbirdSvejoSymbalooTaringa!TelegramTencent QQTencent WeiboTrelloTuentiTypepadUrlaubswerkViadeoViberVirbVisitez Mon SiteVkontaktevKruguDruzeivybrali SMEWaneloWayback MachineWe Heart ItWebMoneyWeChatWhatsAppWhois LookupWishMindrWordPressWykopXINGYahoo MailYammerYoolinkYummlyYuubyZakladok.net

    ZicZac

AddThis






Primary Navigation

    HOME
    ABOUT
    NOVELS
    ANTHOLOGIES
    ESSAYS
    CONTACT

ANIL MENON
Kolam: What The Hand Said
October 31, 2005 /

    Art Culture History

Kolam: What The Hand Said

is this:

    KolamAscher_smallWe here, and that man, this man,
    and that other in-between,
    and that woman, this woman,
    and that other, whoever,

    those people, and these,
    and these others in-between,
    this thing, that thing,
    and this other in-between, whichever

    all things dying, these things,MalekulaBoy_small
    those things, those others in-between,
    good things, bad things,
    things that were, that will be,

    being all of them,
    he stands there.

The God in Nammalvar’s hymn (or rather, A. K. Ramnujan’s translation of it [9, pp. 120-121]) is a god of thresholds. The threshold is of enormous interest to the Tamils. For example, the classical corpus of Tamil poetry is traditionally divided into akam (interior) poems and puram (exterior) poems [10]. The kolam is but one of the many manifestations of that interest

Marcia Ascher’s description of the kolam is succinct and mostly accurate:

    Traditionally, the women of Tamil Nadu, in southeastern India, sweep their thresholds every morning, sprinkle them with a solution of cow dung and water and cover the area with elaborate, symmetrical figures using rice powder. They trickle the rice powder in a stream between their middle and index fingers, using their thumbs to guide the flow of the powder. According to tradition, the cow dung cleans and purifies the ground, and using the rice powder begins the day with an act of kindness by providing food for ants and other insects. Girls learn this kolam ritual from their female relatives, and kolam skills are viewed as a mark of grace and as a demonstration of dexterity, mental discipline and ability to concentrate. [1]

It is doubtful whether kolams are geometrical acts of kindness. It’s also doubtful whether kolams are purificatory acts. They could be; most things are usually lots of things. There are a great many ways to purify something in Indian tradition, but kolams are unique, more or less, to south India. What do the kolam-artists say when they’re asked why they draw these gorgeous graphs?

Fortunately, the anthropologist Lance Nelson asked that very question in his recent doctoral study of the kolam tradition [7]. One of his respondents from Thilaikkudi village in Thanjavur District, a women in her fifties, explained that:

    Bhumi Devi [earth goddess] is our mother. She is everyone’s source of existence. Nothing would exist without her. The entire world depends on her for sustenance and life. So, we draw the kolam first to remind ourselves of her. All day we walk on Bhumi Devi. All night we sleep on her. We spit on her. We poke her. We burden her. We do everything on her. We expect her to bear us and all the activities we do on her with endless patience. That is why we do the kolam. [7, pp. 273]

It seems almost churlish to question the matter further. Yet, I can’t help wondering. Why draw geometrical figures to thank someone? Why not chant a simple prayer or two? Why not heap a pile of rice if the intent is to feed ants and insects (wouldn’t the ants prefer a heap as opposed to trudging alone a maze)? Why aren’t people in the Eastern, Western, and Northern parts of India driven by a similar sense of remorse and gratitude? Why is the Ganges — equally beloved and equally abused — not thanked in a similar manner. What makes Bhumi-devi special? Besides, if gratitude is the point of the  performance, why allow it to be summarily destroyed by the first person to cross the threshold? Indeed, why draw it on the threshold at all?

In particular, take a second look at the boy (figure above) drawing graphs in the sand. The boy’s from Malekula, the second-largest island of Vanuatu. He, like the women of Tamil Nadu, is also engaged in an ancient performance. Why are their drawings so similar?

The Republic of Vanuatu is an archipelago, about 1000 miles east of Australia; it is so small an entity that on most maps it is just a half-hearted pixel blur†. Malekula was the subject of intense anthropological interest during the threshold years of the last century. The reasons go a little deeper beyond the usual anthropological obsessions with bizarre kinship-structures, weird religions and tribal routes to sex (Marvin Gaye, 50 proof alcohol, lots of talk, sometimes even a little dancing). It had been realized that the Melanesian† sand drawings and associated myths had an uncanny resemblance to the labyrinth patterns and associated myths found in Crete, Central Africa, Scandinavia, Ireland and Scotland. It was the complex of parallels — not just similarity in diagrams — that was intriguing. For some still poorly understood reason, megalithic cultures (roughly 1000 – 300 B.C.E) seem to have settled on the labyrinth as the key to the spiritual control of thresholds.

Laynard KolamsConsider this example taken from the work of the British anthropologist John Layard (1891–1974), the man responsible for triggering most of the interest in Malekula [4,5]. The “tic-tac-toe” figure on the left is from Malekula; the one of the right is a tattoo pattern from Tamil Nadu†. Layard thought the Tamil Nadu design “technologically degraded” as compared to the one from Malekula; the latter is a true maze, is produced by a single line and looks more complicated on the whole. Perhaps the “tic-tac-toe” pattern is just a coincidence; after all, it is only a variant on the basic idea of the square. The square is, well, square. Very well. How about KolamMalekula2_smallthis figure then, also taken from one of John Layard’s papers [4]? Ignore the horizontal and vertical dimension lines; they were added by Bernard Deacon, from whom Layard copied the drawing. The object on the left is from Malekula; the one on the right is the “pavitram” kolam. As such, the two figures are not identical. For example, the Malekula design can be obtained from a single line, the one from Tamil Nadu is made up of three sets of lines. But it’s curiously similar. It’s as if one figure is a remembered version of the other. The connection between kolams and Malekula sand-figures was not noticed by Layard (who was unaware of the existence of kolams), but by F. A. Richards. The latter had heard about the Malekulan figures at a meeting of the Cambridge Anthropological Club in 1927; he immediately sent Layard two Indian books filled with kolam diagrams. Also at that meeting was an Indian lady, one Mrs. Gnana Durai. In her words:

    On October 19th, 1927, Dr. Haddon read a paper before the Cambridge Anthropological Club on the late Mr. A. B. Deacon’s investigations in Malekula, in which he referred to and showed examples of the geometrical diagrams which Mr. Deacon had discovered in that island. This at once recalled to my mind that analogous diagrams are constructed every day among the Hindus of the Madras Presidency. [2]

This cross-cultural pattern recognition suggests that there is a similarity between the figures. In any event, the more significant aspect of these diagrams is what they represent to their respective cultures. In Malekula, the sand-diagrams represent labyrinths marking the boundary between the end of one life and the beginning of the next. Only men are reborn, and their rebirth is in their hands, so to speak. As John Layard puts it:

    … the object of the [Egyptian] labyrinth was in the first place to exclude the uninitiated from participation in the life after death, and in the second to exclude non-fertile or unlucky influences from the royal nuptials.
    In Malekula, these one-time royal rites have become democratized to include the whole male population. Here, the mortuary labyrinth has been reduced to a geometric design drawn in the sand by a female Guardian ghost. As the ghost of the dead man approaches (for men only can attain future life) she rubs out half the design. The dead man must complete the design and walk over it before entering the land of the dead.” [4, pp. 117]

Labyrinth_smallLayard argues that kolams retain much of this symbolism. They too are drawn on thresholds. They too are associated with transition stages, such as sunrise, birth, death and marriage ceremonies. It is the women who draw the kolams, and it is usually the man of the house who first walks over it, erasing what has just been drawn. Just as the physical mortuary labyrinth of Crete got abstracted out into a sand-figure representation in the Malekula culture, amongst the Tamil, the idea of the labyrinth got gradually displaced by the  even more abstract notion of threshold. The diagrams were retained, but the interpretations changed, so much so that the current explanations for why the kolam is drawn have no resemblance to the reasons of the Malekulan native.

There are many other connections as well. The word “kolam” refers to a kind of dance in Sri Lanka, one involving masks and complicated steps. The Malekula also have masked dances in which they play out the shapes of particular  sand-diagrams. So on and so forth. It really is an anthropological wet-dream.

Layard speculated, in passing, that both kolams and Malekula sand-diagrams were offshoots of a single megalithic culture, possibly of east or south-east asian in origin [4, pp. 118]. Recent genetic studies would seem to support this theory. Given the nature of genetic studies, the data could probably be tweaked to support almost any other hypothesis. For all we know, one of Thor Heyerdahl’s ancestors may have seeded the whole damn Melanesian world.

Of course, it’s always possible that disparate and widely distributed groups of people independently arrived at the same representations. Events and symbols are always perceived in the context of human space, human time and human experience. Who knows? Perhaps our common genetic heritage may well imply a compulsion for, say, labyrinth designs. In the threshold years of the last century, such compulsions were called archetypes, supposedly architectonic features of the human consciousness. John Layard himself became a Jungian psychologist in his later years.

Point is, even if human groups have very similar concerns (puberty, death, sex, etc.), there is no reason why they should reify similar representations to deal with those concerns. I find it much more likely that different groups of migrating people modified aspects of a once common belief system (“common” for historical — not psychological — reasons).

So it shouldn’t come as any great surprise that there are other cultures who’ve also institutionalized “sand-drawings.” The Navajo Indians (who learnt it from the Pueblo Indians) and the Chokwe in southwestern Africa (Angola, Zambia, Congo) are two outstanding examples. The Chokwe (pronounced, it seems, “chock-way”) have added the ingenious and elegant twist of telling stories as they draw the figures; the abstract diagram is the representation of a story [3].

SiromoneyGrammar_smallThe Chokwe sensed and practiced a mathematical truth. Every kolam is a sentence in some picture language. The mathematical study of kolams, initiated by the remarkable Dr. Gift Siromoney at Madras Christian College and his colleaguesBased on the references to kolams in the literature, Dr. Siromoney claimed that kolams were a relatively recent tradition, less than 500 years old. I think he was incorrect on this point. Kolams were a woman’s art, and as such, unlikely to have been of interest to male writers. For example, there are hardly any ancient/medieval Tamil books on the art of cooking or sweeping or washing clothes either. Siromoney is also unable to explain why women in south India — of all castes — should’ve suddenly developed a taste for abstract geometrical figures in the mid-15th century. Not only is Layard able to give an origins story, it also explains the puzzling, alternative meanings of the word “kolam” [4, pp. 178-180].†, is based on the theory of cycle and matrix grammars [figure on right is from Dr. Rani Siromoney’s lecture slides]. One of the simplest of Siromoney’s grammars consists of “actions” such as “keep going”, “sharp left turn”, “sharp right turn”, “right U-turn”, “left U-turn”, and so on. By the repeated application of about seven actions in a proper sequence, most kolams, but not all, can be produced. To draw a kolam is to “speak” a sentence from a picture language†.

I’m glad to report the kolam tradition continues in Tamil Nadu. More or less. Traditionalists bemoan the introduction of stencils; the skill has been taken out of the tradition. There are dozens of different stencils; aeroplane kolams, sofa kolams, chariot kolams, you name it. Given unlimited rice-powder, ambition alone limits the imagination.

Untitled--pollock_yellow300-1949Can we end without invoking the greatest kolam artist of all? I refer to Jackson Pollock and his celebrated style of “action painting.” The artist has gone on record as saying that he was influenced by the sand drawings of the Navajo Indians [6]. Thresholds cannot exist without difference, and any difference creates a threshold. About Pollock and the art of indifference, the art critic Edward Levine wrote:

    The experience of a painting by Pollock is almost totally unique in art. In his drip painting we sense the almost complete abolition of difference. All lines are equal in value, all parts practically interchangeable so that we have a painting without a dominant direction and without beginning or end. The fact that Pollock walks around and “into” his painting as it evolves is reflected in the lack of hierartic value in this work. Foreground and background, right and left, up and down are hardly distinguishable.” [6]

Poor mad Pollock. The erasure of difference ultimately necessitated his own self-erasure as well; the painter and the painting, something here and something there, this people and those people and others in-between… being all of them, and perhaps in the end, nothing at all.
References:
[1] Ascher, M.  The Kolam Tradition. American Scientist. 90(1). pp. 56. 2002.

[2] Durai, G. H. Preliminary Note On Geometrical Diagrams (Kolam) From The Madras Presidency. Man. Volume 29. May. 1929. pp. 77.

[3] Gerdes, P. Geometry From Africa: Mathematical And Educational Explorations. Mathematical Association of America. Washington, DC. 1999.

[4] Layard, J. Labyrinth Ritual In South India: Threshold And Tattoo Designs. Folklore. 48(2). 1937. pp. 115-182.

[5] Layard, J. Maze-Dances And The Ritual Of The Labyrinth in Malekula. Folklore. 47(2). 1936. pp. 123-170.

[6] Levine, E. Mythical Overtones In The Work of Jackson Pollock. Art Journal. 26(4). pp. 366-374. 1967.

[7] Nelson, L. E. Purifying the Earthly Body of God: Religion and Ecology in Hindu India. State University of New York Press. Albany, NY. 1998.
[8] Pingree, D. The Logic of Non-Western Science: Mathematical Discoveries in Medieval
India. Daedalus. 132(4). 2003. pp. 45-53.

[9] Ramanujan, A. K. Collected Essays. Vinay Dharwadker, editor. Oxford India. 2004.

[10] Ramanujan, A. K. Poems of Love and War: From the Eight Anthologies and the Ten Long Poems of Classical Tamil. Columbia University Press. New York. 1985.

Previous Article
Caste, Closure & Contagion
Next Article
Tribhanga: Strike A Pose
You may also like

    Bee and Lotus
    Say, lovely woman, the number of bees: Bhaskara’s Lilavati
    Art Books Culture History Indian Authors Mathematics Writing
    Adinatha danseuse
    Tribhanga: Strike A Pose
    Culture History
    Naiyar Masud: The Storyteller of Lucknow
    Art Books Culture Current Affairs Indian Authors Writing

There are 29 comments

    Shruthi    on November 2, 2005 at 11:25 pm

    Hi.. Very interesting write up! This has inspired me to do more reading on this topic…. by the way, this tradition continues in Karnataka too… it is called Rangavalli (Rangoli in Hindi)
    Shruthi    on November 2, 2005 at 11:25 pm

    Hi.. Very interesting write up! This has inspired me to do more reading on this topic…. by the way, this tradition continues in Karnataka too… it is called Rangavalli (Rangoli in Hindi)
    Anil Menon    on November 3, 2005 at 6:36 am

    Thanks Shruthi. Rangoli seems to be more of an art form. Kolam-drawing has a lot of religious symbolism and rules associated with it. But I don’t know much about rangoli.
    Subbu    on November 3, 2005 at 3:33 pm

    Excellent piece of research! In Andhra Pradesh, kolam is “muggu” (‘mu’ pronounced as in ‘murali’)& in Kerala, “kalam”. An observation: Kolam is not restricted to being drawn outside the house. In brahmin households, it also is drawn in front of the lord, in the puja room. Any act of disturbing it would be a sacrilege. This does seem to suggest some kind of a demarcation of the areas between the lord and the devotee,perhaps indicating a threshold.
    mani    on November 4, 2005 at 8:21 pm

    Nice work. Thanks for a well researched and interesting article. It is interesting to see how this custom is practiced in different parts of India (mainly). The way I remember it, kolams are predominantly drawn using dots and lines only, while rangoli is free form with emphasis on colors.
    Nagata Shojiro    on July 12, 2006 at 7:22 am

    Very nice works
    I am also interested in the Stroke/knot patterns in the world.
    I made a software which allow us to draw them in animation
    Let’s enjoy Cycles(called PsyKolo) at
    http://intervision.aadau.net/
    and now
    Welcome to the Conference at
    http://wwwsoc.nii.ac.jp/form/62th-sympo.htm
    I wrote a chapter “Digitalization of Kolam Patterns
    and Tactile Kolam Tools (S Nagata & R Thamburaj )” in the book
    http://www.worldscibooks.com/compsci/6180.html
    -from Nagata Shojiro/InterVision Institute
    Anil Menon    on July 13, 2006 at 2:21 am

    Nagata, thanks for the links. I’d been looking for graphic tools. I wonder if 2-D projections of origami structures would result in kolam like patterns…
    Uma    on April 28, 2007 at 8:57 pm

    Hi
    Check out my new blog on kolam
    http://www.kolam-sathya.blogspot.com
    Ur comments r welcome.
    sita    on May 17, 2007 at 4:57 am

    Hi
    I do kolams .&try to read ,as much as possible,about it.I came across the african variety in a childrens book on mathematical games published by Scholastic.&was intrgued by the way the same kolam that I do is also done in Africa&now thru your blog even in Vanuatu.-only the names seem different.Even within our country ,Kolams are done in almost all the states;only the materials used are different.They are also called Mandana(in Rajasthan,U.P.,M.P),alpana in bengal& bihar.I think it is the Kolams that influence the othr art forms -Tattoos(its not confined to tribals,all tamil hindus practise it-tho’ not prevalent now)Kasuti embroidery in Karnataka etc.From what I’ve read ,kolams seem to exist in Harrappan Times too.The swastic and the Shatkonam is common thru’ out india.It is considered the abode of Lakshmi&hence is not stepped on.The threshold is always crossed over not stepped on(the Narasimha legend).In our tradition it is also a device to show directions-esplly the east.I never cease to be amazed at the areas the Kolam seems to touch.I personally know it to be associated with the the field of psychology-I dont know if any research has been done to study the connection.By the way rangoli is also Kolam,but with colour.Thanks for the informative &interesting site.Regards
    Sita
    Anil Menon    on May 17, 2007 at 6:25 am

    Ref: Sita. Thanks for the additional info. I’m intrigued by your comment that kolams are associated with psychology. Care to elaborate?
    Kolams do seem to be ubiquitous. Based on the written Tamil corpus, Dr. Siromoney and his colleagues thought them to be of recent origin (~ 500 years). But that estimate is almost certainly wrong (for reasons described in the footnote).
    sita    on June 2, 2007 at 9:06 am

    Anil, Regarding kolams and Psych.-Ifirst came across a book by Dr. Reuven Feuerstein in 2002 titled “Dont accept me as I am”.It was about helping “retarded” people excel.in it I came across an excercise where the student is asked to find given shapes from dots scattered in the frame.The stellar arrangements into constellations was reported to be the inspiration for this exercise.I had attended a workshop on Instrumental Enrichment(the method developed by Dr. F’stein et al)to help people improve their mental potential conducted By his Institute & their Indian co-ordinators-the Alpha to Omega School for Learning Disabled.These methods are widely used to improve the mental functioning of the so called Mentally handicapped children(so called b’coz i believe all of us are handicapped in one way or other).Because of my familiarity with Kolams ,I realised that Kolams work in the same way as Organisation of Dots ,as the exercise is called by them.Many peoplwe in India while they are familiar with kolam dont realise the way it helps them think better.It improves our abilitty to think things/issues thru,analyse ,&synthesise information ,plan things,acquire -process-express information and also recall information ; in short it not only shows us the state of our intelligence/mind but also helps us to improve its functions by acting on the brain .It is about the way the brain processes information.May be one day i’ll write a paper on it.Your note tells me that not many people are aware of the connection.Hope this note clarifies your doubts.
    sita    on June 2, 2007 at 9:06 am

    Anil, Regarding kolams and Psych.-Ifirst came across a book by Dr. Reuven Feuerstein in 2002 titled “Dont accept me as I am”.It was about helping “retarded” people excel.in it I came across an excercise where the student is asked to find given shapes from dots scattered in the frame.The stellar arrangements into constellations was reported to be the inspiration for this exercise.I had attended a workshop on Instrumental Enrichment(the method developed by Dr. F’stein et al)to help people improve their mental potential conducted By his Institute & their Indian co-ordinators-the Alpha to Omega School for Learning Disabled.These methods are widely used to improve the mental functioning of the so called Mentally handicapped children(so called b’coz i believe all of us are handicapped in one way or other).Because of my familiarity with Kolams ,I realised that Kolams work in the same way as Organisation of Dots ,as the exercise is called by them.Many peoplwe in India while they are familiar with kolam dont realise the way it helps them think better.It improves our abilitty to think things/issues thru,analyse ,&synthesise information ,plan things,acquire -process-express information and also recall information ; in short it not only shows us the state of our intelligence/mind but also helps us to improve its functions by acting on the brain .It is about the way the brain processes information.May be one day i’ll write a paper on it.Your note tells me that not many people are aware of the connection.Hope this note clarifies your doubts.
    Anil Menon    on June 2, 2007 at 9:57 am

    Sita: Interesting…. But I’m skeptical. I doubt kolams are ways to help us think better; they might, but if that were the point of kolams, why is the art restricted to women (in India)? Are kolam practitioners noted for their analytical skills? Besides, while geometrical reasoning is one kind of cognitive skill, surely there are many other types. Howard Gardener’s ideas on the many kinds of minds would seem to be closer to the truth.
    Nagata shojiro    on December 24, 2007 at 2:26 am

    I am glad to contact with you as a researcher interested in Kolam or other traditional string cycle patterns.
    I am glad to announce that
    It has Just passed one year since the time when we had held the international symposium on katachi/form in folk/traditional arts(ISKFA06 Japan)
    After a long time, we now published the commemorative issue of the journal
    (English version) FORMA and now uploaded all texts of it to the free web
    http://www.scipress.org/journals/forma/frame/22.html
    of one of the co-organizations Society for Science on Form, Japan
    http://wwwsoc.nii.ac.jp/form/index.html (sorry mostly in Japanese)
    The figure of the cover page is Kolam image calld as Diamond
    Carpet and the four color traces show that the original pattern looks like
    in Chaos, however consists clearly of the structure of Swastika with
    rotating symmetry, and the web image display the animation of that tracing.
    I am considering to send you to a copy(s for co-authors) of a printed matter of the Journal with surface/air mail.
    Please give me your any comments or opinion about it.
    http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=l8Atlvc9UVA
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGwt306KUB8
    produced by me, show some movies introducing how to draw Kolam in India with real performances
    Thanks again
    with best regards
    Nagata shojiro (KASF) the editor in chief of this issue
    Nagata shojiro    on January 7, 2008 at 8:26 pm

    Dear Sita you mentioned about school for learning disabled and Kolam works.
    I was interested in it very much, as I have tried to Knot/Kolam patterns for making any handicap persons enjoy it and for training our brain as well.
    please find my paper in the list of poster papers in
    http://www.icevi.org/publications/access_to_curricular.html
    one teacher of a junior high school of my friends is applying kolam/Psykolo block developed by men for her learning disabled class
    do you know some books for drawing education
    http://www.hawthornpress.com/books/cfd-123.html
    or Rudolf Steiner education, which seems be originated in celtic knot deign in old Europe?
    if you would like to discuss with me on it,
    please contact with me on
    invsn@cityfujisawa.ne.jp
    best regards
    Nagata
    Nagata shojiro    on March 4, 2008 at 7:46 pm

    Sita responded in her web
    http://sita-tangledweb.blogspot.com/search/label/Dysgraphia
    Nagata shojiro    on July 27, 2008 at 4:36 am

    > I think he ( Dr. Siromoney) was incorrect on this point.
    > Layard is not only able to give an origins story, but it also explains the puzzling, alternative meanings of the word “kolam”.
    Very interesting for me,
    As I am writing an article of cycle-loop patterns in the Encyclopedia for Form, Function and Design in Japanese.
    In the chapter of Culture and Living,
    I would like to introduce Kolam of your countries including Celtic
    Knots, Sona, Nitus, Arabesque etc.
    So may I ask you to help/inform the following questions;
    When (in how many years ago ) do Such cycle patterns originate ?
    What purpose these patterns were drawn/painted for on the ground ?
    Especially what did/were Dots mean/represented as well as Cycles/loops ?
    I know Rangoli has very wide variations of each state and also Kolam has effected by them now. But I would like to let me know about designs which consist of dot arrangemnts and loops around dots or connected with dots.
    1:I am not able to read Layard’s paper, so please introduce his claims about them.
    2:I know and saw some Hindu priests (men) were drawing Kolam at the threshold of a small temple in a street in front of Meenakshi in Madurai, and also saw some Kolam on the floors in Meenakshi and other hindu temples.
    so, We are able to expect other Hindu literatures, where Kolam were explained as very important religious matters even the painters were only women for thier houses.
    Personally I think this traditional performance has started more eariler than 500 years ago.
    thanks very much for your helps in advance
    Nagata Shojiro
    Anonymous    on July 27, 2008 at 7:29 am

    Nagata:
    If I remember Layard’s paper correctly, his theory is that originally, the diagrams were representations of labyrinths, with the labyrinth itself symbolizing the stage between life and death. It’s a bit like how the cross represents Jesus’s sacrifice; the sacrifice itself represents/seals/symbolizes a contract with a divine authority. Later on, the symbolism and representation evolved differently in cultures as people migrated over the globe. In the Tamils, the transition from life to death got abstracted into the notion of threshold. On the other hand, in Vanuatu, much of the original significance of these diagrams seems to have been retained.
    The oldest labyrinth diagram (~2500 B.C.) is possibly the Tomba del Labirinto at Luzzanas on the island of Sardinia. See http://www.labyrinthos.net/luzzanas35.htm for details. It dates the origin to the Neolithic period.
    The original diagrams did not have dots; the dots basically are meant to help in the construction of the digram.
    Kolam-drawing is generally considered a feminine task in Tamil Nadu (which is one reason why it was of little interest to the male writers). Priests are an interesting exception.
    I suggest you ignore folk explanations of why kolams are drawn. I don’t think kolams have anything to do with expressing gratitude towards Mother Earth or warding off evil or any such thing. The truth is Indians have forgotten. They do it now mostly because their ancestors did it. But the original impulse for these diagrams are now to be found only in a few isolated places like Vanuatu.
    Nagata shojiro    on July 27, 2008 at 11:05 am

    Thanks the responder(maybe Anil) very much.
    1: Sorry I could not visit Vanuatu and also find any Sand paintings of Cycle patterns in the web world except some designs of tattoo.
    So, I think at the present time Kolam is mostly conserved/kept in daily lifes in the world. Could We find any photo/picture (like the BOY in this page)shown in the website ?
    2: Yes, peoples sometimes have forgot why they began to do so in thier traditional performance but only keep in form or for modern pouporse (decoration with Kolam paiting)
    3: Some Webpage (sorry I did not find the URL now again) explain “Dots are siva and strokes are sakthi” or “The dots signify hurdles and problems in life. Our life begins from the Lord, runs around various hurdles and finally ends again with the Lord”. What your opinion about them? In Sona, the dot mean some places, like a rock or an animal etc.
    4: There is simular structurs in form with celtic knot deign in old (pre-Roman) Europe rather than labyrinths. What do you (or did Layard) think about it?
    5:Again When (in how many years ago ) were Such cycle patterns started especially with Dots for Cycles/loops?
    Anil Menon    on July 27, 2008 at 12:01 pm

    Nagata:
    Item #1: See the Maria Ascher article (ref #1) for the photograph. She also has a book, I think, on ethno-mathematics that has other pictures. Why not contact people in Vanuatu? They may be able to help.
    Item # 3: I wouldn’t take such stories seriously. There’s nothing in the literature to support these “explanations.” When it comes to Hinduism and its practices, the web is a very unreliable resource.
    Item# 4: Based on the similarity of the designs and the relative ages of civilizations, Layard believed that the European designs were carried over via migration from the old Mediterranean civilizations. It’s hard to be 100% sure since drawings are difficult to date; what one carbon-dates are the stones on which they’re drawn. And of course the Celts may have come up the idea by themselves too.
    Item #5: It’s not known. Such diagrams have been found on grave-stones in Goa, dated as far back as 2500 B.C. The actual origins probably go back much earlier. Only a few places in India have been explored by archaeologists.
    Nagata shojiro    on July 27, 2008 at 8:39 pm

    Thanks Anil-san
    item#1 Yes, I read her paper sent by herself, and know “In the navigation tradition of People of the Marshall Islands” Maybe this island means Vanuatu. I contacted some people related with Vanuatu State incuding the Ambasy, but no information of Sand Painting Nitus. Would you know any person, who would be able to inform at the present time on it? I would like to know Sona or Nitus are drawing by people in daily lifes like Kolam or If we could see them, when we visit there.
    #3: Ascher introduced “the Tamilu literature only refers to the Kolam in passing and includes little detail. and for example one of the earlist know references, a 16th Cntry writing, telles about a peaceful and flourishing Kingdom and Kolam ,,,,,, ”
    #4 Yes, I think most Old celtic knot like pattern was a line of two twisted lopes, which is seen in the mosaic pictures in some ruins/remains realted with Israel or other places
    #5 I greatly appreciate some information introducing that refereable article and also photo
    thanks again
    Anil Menon    on July 27, 2008 at 9:24 pm

    Nagata:
    #3 (references to Kolams in Tamil lit): Yes, there are few references before the 15th century. Several possible reasons: (1) most writing was on palm-leaf manuscripts — quite perishable; (2) kolams were considered a feminine art and not of much interest to male writers; and (3) daughters learnt by watching and imitating their mothers, not from books. Also, since most people in Ancient and Medieval India did not read and write, it makes more sense to see if there are references to kolams in old songs. That I do not know.
    #5 (Labyrinth occurrences in Goa): This link might be useful: http://www.labyrinthos.net/indialabs.htm
    Sorry I can’t help you with Vanuatu. But let me know, and I’ll send you copies of Layard’s papers.
    Nagata shojiro    on July 28, 2008 at 5:08 am

    thanks Anil-san
    My postal address is
    Nagata Shojiro
    InterVision Institute
    4-24,Katase-5, Fujisawa
    Japan 251-0032
    # 5 Interesting story that Labyrinth changed to Kolam pattern
    I would like to know that evolution.
    http://net.community.city.fujisawa.kanagawa.jp/conference/conferroom.php?CONFERNO=318
    writen in Japanese but you may find some pictures with clicking
    some postings with an left icon.
    thanks Nagata
    William    on August 9, 2008 at 2:48 pm

    I have used Lusona, Rangavalli and Drami patterns with Mathematics Teachers from around the world to exemplify the way that mathematics has always been a part of all cultures, but that this form of mathematics has been ignored as part of the formal school geometry syllabus. On my web page (www.cyffredin.co.uk ) are some simple mathematical investigations that my students and I have developed out of the traditionsl geometrical patterns, such as Drami and Rangavalli.
    I have been fascinated to read all the comments on your web page and hope some readers might like to try experimenting with our activities as a part of school mathematics lessons
    William
    Anil Menon    on August 9, 2008 at 7:17 pm

    William: Thanks. The Drami figures were new to me.
    Incidentally, Laura Maffei and Franco Favillia in the Dept. of Mathematics at the University of Pisa have used Sona diagrams of the Tchockwe people to teach high-school students the GCD and other simple arithmetical concepts. Email me (anilm at acm dot org ) if you’d like a copy of their paper.
    Nagata Shojiro    on October 15, 2008 at 7:47 pm

    Dear Anil menon san
    >Sorry I can’t help you with Vanuatu.
    > But let me know, and I’ll send you copies of Layard’s papers.
    Thank you for your kindness
    I have wait it so long but not has not come to Japan
    Would you check it Please?
    thanks in advance
    nagata
    VARSHA    on February 9, 2009 at 9:53 pm

    Hello Anil,
    Brilliant work – amomng all the stuff on the internet, yours is the ONLY authentic one that gives a wide angled perspective.
    And I agree with your statement – that the web is an unreliable source when it comes to Hindusim and its practices.
    I am now reseraching Kolam and I need some information from you.
    1.can you send me by email the paper published by Layard please?
    2. would you have come across any references in literature that gives an approximate date for the origins of kolam.
    (the web is full of statements that kolam finds a place in Kamasutre (it does not) Kolam is one of the 64 arts mentioned in Bhagavatham (it is not one of the 64 arts) and so on…I have not been able to locate any authentic date for the origins. if you chance upon anything, please let me know. In the meanwhile if I am successful in my quest in dating this art form I will also inform you.
    Many thanks
    Varsha
    Anil Menon    on February 10, 2009 at 6:12 am

    Hi Varsha,
    Thanks for the kind comments. Personally, I’m a bit appalled by the blog’s, um, verbosity. 🙂 The article just grew and grew.
    I’m really glad you’ve decided to take up the problem of dating the art form. I’ll send Layard’s papers. I’ll also send a paper by Jerome Jacobson on South Asian prehistory which might be useful. If we know people X were drawing kolam-type figures at date Y and they moved into the subcontinent around a later date Z, then we have prehistoric desis drawing kolams at around date Z. If you find anything, please let me know.
    Anil
    VARSHA    on February 10, 2009 at 3:26 pm

    Thank you Anil for the papers. And Yes, your logic seems like a good one for dating this art form.
    Let me have a read first.
    Thanks again, Varsha

Comments are closed.

    twitter
    facebook
    gplus
    rss




hattip to the triggereurs of this trouvaille 

Peter  Duke and Jay Dyer


Dyer on The Shining
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJCxoRW71fo
 The Shining EXPLAINED - Full Documentary Breakdown
Jay Dyer
109K subscribers
102,607 views  May 20, 2021
Never before made public! Be sure and subscribe to my channel! Like my previous film analyses and book, this work covers the hidden meanings and symbols encoded in Kubrick's version of King's The Shining.  Differing and agreeing with other analysts, I take a route others have not.  This is a classic analysis that for subscribers only I'm temporarily making public. Enjoy!
29th minute on john layard 1937 'the malekulan journey of the dead' [mazes]
66Mb pdf [about 6 copies in suggs .. this one w most views from 2017 [a thousand] for its 900 pages ..
https://archive.org/details/in.gov.ignca.2108
 Stone men of Malekula Vao

by Layard, John --1942 ---Archeological Survey, Asians, Biochemistry, Archaeology ----- Source URL: http://asi.nic.in/asi_books/2108.pdf

middle of a minute long scan of a page from a sibling Layard book
29th minute on john layard 'the malekulan journey of the dead' [mazes]
https://youtu.be/CJCxoRW71fo?t=1727
there's a rectangle version in this one

page 3 is 32pdf

85 + 29 = 114

737 i find what i am after ... p656

beach trace labyrinth matrix plough pattern
single line cross stitch mandala ghost ferriman sigil

.... it's on page .... not visible ... dumb Jay ain't linkin to the book either and if archive.org has it, the author's name does not bring it up ...




a connect i expected is Aby Warburg but that did not materialize; a vids on/with him:

aby warburg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgaCYYvD9zg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4U9t6YOQM0




https://arjunpuriinqatar.blogspot.com/2017/08/rangoli-kolam-designs-and-what-they-mean.html

Monday, 21 August 2017
Rangoli, Kolam designs and what they mean


http://www.tetraskele.com/sacred_science/mythology_deciphered.html
©2013 Dorian Taddei
KOLAM • LABYRINTH CONNECTION


in my batch from subbed 'NewsVandals'

ODDS, ENDS
What Time is It on the Moon? It May Get its Own Timezone
https://www.universetoday.com/160453/what-time-is-it-on-the-moon-it-may-get-its-own-timezone/

Our heartbeats cause "wrinkles in time" says new study
https://newatlas.com/biology/heartbeats-time-perception/

 

dinsdag 21 februari 2023

Holodomor: StalinPlayers prepun is hment


 Holodomor: Stalin's Secret Genocide
Hrytsko
2.43K subscribers
29,533 views  Feb 6, 2017
An estimated ten million Ukrainians died in the early 1930s in a genocide known as Holodomor. Find out more about the incident that inspired the film Bitter Harvest.

2016
Written and directed by: Andrea Chalupa
Narrated by: Andy Holowaty
Music:
*"March for the Young Nakhimovets" by Loktev Choir
* "Ne Khody Ulane" by the Lemon Bucket Orchestra
* "Oj Polia Vy Polia" by the Lemon Bucket Orchestra

Produced by:
Holodomor National Awareness Tour
Ukrainian Canadian Research and Documenation Center
Holodomor Research and Education Consortium
Ukrainian Canadian Congress
Canada Ukraine Foundation